Inventor 2022.3: Deleting a reference dimension in a sketch breaks the sketch = "problems encountered while executing this command"

Inventor 2022.3: Deleting a reference dimension in a sketch breaks the sketch = "problems encountered while executing this command"

jeffg28CLY
Collaborator Collaborator
579 Views
3 Replies
Message 1 of 4

Inventor 2022.3: Deleting a reference dimension in a sketch breaks the sketch = "problems encountered while executing this command"

jeffg28CLY
Collaborator
Collaborator

I'm working up some quick-fire, messily-made 3d prints of some profile variations to try out.

I added a reference dimension, I think it was by an accidental misclick, so I went to delete it.

...That broke the sketch:

If I try deleting the .260 reference dimension near the bottom-center there, nearly every dimension on the sketch turns pink to show they're broken, and Inventor says "Delete Selections: problems encountered while executing this command."

 

I guess something got corrupted somehow? How does deleting a newly-created reference dimension break a sketch?

 

Part file is attached.

Open up Sketch 1, and delete (.260). You should immediately get the error message.

 

holder.png

0 Likes
Accepted solutions (1)
580 Views
3 Replies
Replies (3)
Message 2 of 4

Alexander_Chernikov
Mentor
Mentor

The problem may be that the sketch is not fully constrained (it needs 2 constrains).
If you add the shown angular dimension, then you can delete the dimension (.260) without error.
But there is one more unspecified parameter.

holder.png
The corrected file is attached.

Do you find the posts helpful? "LIKE" these posts! | Відповідь корисна? Клікніть на "ВПОДОБАЙКУ" цім повідомленням!
Have your question been answered successfully? Click "ACCEPT SOLUTION" button. | На ваше запитання відповіли? Натисніть кнопку "ПРИЙНЯТИ РІШЕННЯ"

Олександр Черніков / Alexander Chernikov

EESignature

Facebook | LinkedIn

.


0 Likes
Message 3 of 4

jeffg28CLY
Collaborator
Collaborator

I hadn't gotten that far into the design as to fully constrain the sketch.

But whether a sketch is or isn't fully constrained, I would think that a reference dimension should have absolutely zero effect on the stability of the sketch or model, especially when it's not used by any formulas. I would expect a reference dimension to function entirely like a neutral observer.

0 Likes
Message 4 of 4

Tom_Sturtevant
Alumni
Alumni
Accepted solution
Hi Jeff –

Yes, a reference dimension should be a “neutral observer”. This is definitely a bug and is now tracked as INVGEN-64940.
Thanks for taking the time to report the issue!

T.0.M.


Tom Sturtevant
Inventor Part Modeling Developer
Autodesk, Inc.