Announcements
Autodesk Community will be read-only between April 26 and April 27 as we complete essential maintenance. We will remove this banner once completed. Thanks for your understanding

Body grouping causes hidden objects to export

anton.kuptsovEJSSW
Contributor Contributor
1,312 Views
9 Replies
Message 1 of 10

Body grouping causes hidden objects to export

anton.kuptsovEJSSW
Contributor
Contributor

Just noticed, that if I "hide" some group without hiding directly the bodies that is contains, such objects while invisible to me, will be exported (to STP or whatever) as if they were visible.

 

"Cable-Silicone" will be exported..."Cable-Silicone" will be exported...

6 Likes
1,313 Views
9 Replies
Replies (9)
Message 2 of 10

l_kesiunas
Participant
Participant

Same problem to me, it feels unintuitive. Has anybody got any workarounds without clicking each body and hiding it separately?

1 Like
Message 3 of 10

Anonymous
Not applicable

dans les composants

0 Likes
Message 4 of 10

hrabecj
Observer
Observer
You can select all bodies you want to hide {either SHIFT+click for from-to selection or CTRL+click for individual bodies) and then press V - this toggles visibility of the selected bodies.
0 Likes
Message 5 of 10

hrabecj
Observer
Observer

Even now (01/2021) I am experiencing the same problem, please fix this.

2 Likes
Message 6 of 10

b.jacquesF9G7Y
Participant
Participant
  • Problem still persists as of November 2021
  • Problem is even worse when creating drawings:
    • Create drawing of visible bodies: Grouped bodies are shown in the drawing even though both the group and all contained bodies are turned invisible!
    • Create drawing of selected components: Not applicable since this only allows selection on component level (and we're talking first-level components, not sub-components!), not individual bodies
    • Only solution: Delete the group and "expand contents" - that's in general the only way to get bodies out of a group. Get them into a group - Drag+Drop. Get them out - no way, you have to delete the group completely to free its contents. What if I've got 50 bodies in a group, and want to take only one of them out of the group? Yes, blast the whole group and put the 49 into a new one. Mostly defeats the purpose of groups for me.

It's moments like these when I really miss "professional" CAD programs. Not because of their expensive fancy functions (Fusion has lots of those, too), but because such basic things just work. Fusion? Banana-ware at its finest.

0 Likes
Message 7 of 10

BaronTC
Contributor
Contributor

Hello from August 13, 2022! This just cost me 25 minutes of trying to hide / show / export until I finally realized that it was probably a bug that the FOLDER hide doesn't do anything about the inclusion of bodies on export, only toggles their visibility in the drawing. 

 

Please do fix this.

 

This is maybe low hanging fruit since export already respects a body's visibility flag and would be just a matter of checking the body's group flag?

0 Likes
Message 8 of 10

jeor
Community Visitor
Community Visitor

Despite several Fusion360 updates over the years since this issue was first reported, it's still not resolved!

Does the developers keep an eye on the user comments in this forum at all!?

It's pretty annoying, that one have to hide every body inside the group folder that one do not want to be printed.

If one only hide the bodygroup the bodys isn't visible in the Fusion workspace but they are certanily visible in the exported mesh file. If saved as a 3mf file, the Prusa slicer can't even import the file correctly. Haven't tried other slicers, but I think it would be the same issue.

As mentioned above, please fix this now, thanks.

0 Likes
Message 9 of 10

Steven_Gao
Community Manager
Community Manager

Thanks for reporting this problem. We opened an internal ticket to track this problem.

 

Thanks,

Steven

0 Likes
Message 10 of 10

ricthot
Observer
Observer
Any updates yet? Its really annoying having to go through all grouped bodies individually hiding those we don't want exported?
0 Likes