Floating input drag handle too fiddly

Floating input drag handle too fiddly

Scoox
Collaborator Collaborator
1,093 Views
5 Replies
Message 1 of 6

Floating input drag handle too fiddly

Scoox
Collaborator
Collaborator

The floating input box handle, depicted below, doesn't has a number of issues:

 

2017-12-31 Handle.png

 

1. Hard to grab: The handle is made up of a number of staggered tiny dots. You have to actually click on one of the dots in order to grab the handle, otherwise the click goes through. Therefore about 50% of clicks that are aimed at the handle go through and select whatever is behind, I doubt this is intentional.

 

2. Hard to see: Look at the previous screenshot, the handle is practically impossible to see against the default light gray background.

 

3. The gap: There is an unnecessary gap between the handle and the input box. Clicking in the gap targets whatever is in the background, not the input box:

 

2017-12-31 Gap.png

 

 

In my opinion something like this might be better:

 

2017-12-31 Better handle.png

 

To me this looks cleaner, there is no gap, the extent of the handle area is clearly visible and contrasts well against the default light-gray background. Clicking anywhere within the handle area (dark gray) targets the input box, i.e. no click-through like currently. Fusion 360 should adjust the color of the handle according to the "theme" chosen, to ensure good contrast.

 

One more thing. At the moment, clicking anywhere in the light gray border opens the value presets drop-down. This is counter-intuitive since there is a down-arrow icon to the right of the input box, which sort of implies "here's were you should click to expand the drop-down". I don't have a huge problem with the this, although in my opinion it would be better to allow dragging the box by any area of the border, just my opinion. For example, in the following mock-up, the input box could be dragged by the blue area, and the drop-down would be expanded by clicking the red area:

 

2017-12-31 Areas.png 2017-12-31 Areas color.png

 

Thanks and happy new year!

 

 

1,094 Views
5 Replies
Replies (5)
Message 2 of 6

Scoox
Collaborator
Collaborator

Bad editing... My post was meant to read "The floating input box handle, depicted below, doesn't has a number of issues:"

0 Likes
Message 3 of 6

TrippyLighting
Consultant
Consultant

I've been following your many suggestions of how to improve the UI and they've really gotten my attention. They are well thought out and presented.

In one word  Excellent!

 

@brianrepp It might not be a bad idea to collect these and have your UI team evaluate them.

 

 


EESignature

Message 4 of 6

brianrepp
Community Manager
Community Manager
Thanks for the heads up, Peter!

@Scoox when we’re back in the office next week I’ll talk to our UX team.

Happy New Years everyone!
0 Likes
Message 5 of 6

Scoox
Collaborator
Collaborator

Thanks Peter and Brian, and best wishes for 2018!

0 Likes
Message 6 of 6

jeff_strater
Community Manager
Community Manager

Thanks for bringing this up, @Scoox.  It turns out that the problem here was that this handle has some areas that are transparent, so the selection flows through to the stuff behind it.  So, there are only really a few dots that you can use to drag this thing.  I showed this to the UI team, and they were able to fix it by getting rid of those transparent areas.  It has been fixed in our local build, and should appear in the next major update of Fusion.

 

Jeff

 


Jeff Strater
Engineering Director