Thanks Guys,
Looking into this more (and thanks to that screenshot above), I do have the configurations, however I'm using "single user storage".
All of us in my company use single user storage, yet we all share the same project file.
If I switch to team storage, none of my files are shown. When our reseller came in and gave us a quick lesson and set our team up, this is how they set it up, and we never had a reason to change.
We still only use a single "project" for all of our files.
I'll need to somehow move this project into the team storage and then have my other 2 guys use the team storage as well.