Bug for the parameters

[mcappelaere]

On this modeling https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=J6picYSItW8 , Manuel Warland encounters a memorization bug of the "LargeurSlot" parameter. He applies it on 5 Slots. When it changes the value of the parameter, it is not taken into account by the 5 Slots and the parameter must be re-assigned to them as a dimension. Many of us have reported this same bug on my Facebook Group while trying to reproduce the same modeling.

[g-andresen]

Hi,

please share a sample file to take a look at.

File > export > save as f3d on local device  > attach it to the next post.

günther

[mcappelaere]

I created a Slot with diameter = Parameter "try" (11 mm).

I create 4 other Slots with the same Parameter.

If I change "try" = 12 mm, we have mistakes.

[g-andresen]

Hi,

If existing points are used, the parameterization will not be applied during the first dimensioning. It will then work with a new dimensioning.
With free slots it works immediately.

günther

[mcappelaere]

But you don't try to change the Parameter.

[g-andresen]

Hi,

---

@mcappelaere wrote:

But you don't try to change the Parameter.

---

In this situation, the problem is that some measures have not adopted the parameterization. This can be recognized by the missing suffix (fx.)
If after a new dimensioning with assignment of the parameter the P was taken over, this becomes clear by this suffix. Then also changes of the parameters have an effect.

günther

[JeromeBriot]

---

@g-andresen wrote:

If existing points are used, the parameterization will not be applied during the first dimensioning.

@g-andresen, to me this is a bug. The width of the slot is not related to its length. The existing points only constraint the length of the slot. Did I miss something in your explanation?

[mcappelaere]

@guenther.andresen, Yes for me there is a bug !!!

[g-andresen]

Hi,

---

@JeromeBriot wrote:

 Did I miss something in your explanation?

---

In #4 and #6 I described that under certain conditions the assignment of the parameter is not done when creating the slot.
However, when re-dimensioning with the P, this is done.
I leave the decision as to whether this is a bug to e.g. @jeff_strater 

günther