Community
Fusion Manufacture
Talk shop with the Fusion (formerly Fusion 360) Manufacture Community. Share tool strategies, tips, get advice and solve problems together with the best minds in the industry.
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Trying to machine an ellipse and seeing step moves in part

9 REPLIES 9
SOLVED
Reply
Message 1 of 10
hkenuam
225 Views, 9 Replies

Trying to machine an ellipse and seeing step moves in part

I have a simple part that has an inner hole and ellipse shaped outer. When I machine the part I'm seeing each x/y move in part (see picture). I've tried smoothing, using R vs IJ and it some cases seems a bit better but still not acceptable.

 

If you look at the picture you can see the small moves (keep in mind I've gone over it a few times and you can see tool marks). But the individual steps I can't understand. I even thought maybe it's the machine but notice the hole in the center. Absolutely perfect. 

 

hkenuam_0-1676815489650.png

hkenuam_1-1676815527696.png

 

Please help

9 REPLIES 9
Message 2 of 10
seth.madore
in reply to: hkenuam

Could you share your file here? It's not clear from the clipped image of your browser what toolpath may have left that mark.

File > Export > Save to local folder, return to thread and attach the .f3d file in your reply


Seth Madore
Customer Advocacy Manager - Manufacturing
Message 3 of 10
hkenuam
in reply to: hkenuam

I think I see the problem. I exported my ellipse as a .dxf and opened it in BobCad and what you see here is what the machine is doing. The outer ellipse I added using BobCad. 

 

hkenuam_0-1676818169904.png

 

Message 4 of 10
seth.madore
in reply to: hkenuam

BobCad....watch your language 😉

 

Seeing the (Fusion) file would help us to determine if an old bug has popped up again, please share it if you can


Seth Madore
Customer Advocacy Manager - Manufacturing
Message 5 of 10
hkenuam
in reply to: seth.madore

Believe me, I left Bobcad a long long time ago. Fusion has been awesome.

 

Here is the file- btw, I could not include the file as an attachment.

%
O1001
(T19 D=0.75 CR=0. - ZMIN=-0.4 - flat end mill)
G90 G17
G20
M59
G0 M140
(2D Contour15)
T19 M6
S2500 M3
G54
M8
G0 X5.1171 Y-1.3196 Z0.6
G43 H19
Z0.2
G1 Z-0.325 F100.
G3.4 X5.1015 Y-1.304 Z-0.378
X5.064 Y-1.2665 Z-0.4 F40.
G1 G41 X5.0145 Y-1.217 D19
G3 X4.975 Y-1.3125 I0.0955 J-0.0955
G2 X4.9749 Y-1.3199 I-0.375 J0.
G1 X4.9744 Y-1.3477
G2 X4.9737 Y-1.3634 I-0.3749 J0.0074
G1 X4.972 Y-1.3914
G2 X4.9707 Y-1.4068 I-0.3743 J0.0232
G1 X4.9678 Y-1.435
G2 X4.966 Y-1.4499 I-0.373 J0.0385
G1 X4.9619 Y-1.4783
G2 X4.9593 Y-1.4939 I-0.3712 J0.0535
G1 X4.9539 Y-1.5225
G2 X4.9508 Y-1.5375 I-0.3686 J0.0691
G1 X4.9442 Y-1.5663
G2 X4.9404 Y-1.5813 I-0.3654 J0.0841
G1 X4.9325 Y-1.6101
G2 X4.9282 Y-1.6246 I-0.3617 J0.0992
G1 X4.919 Y-1.6536
G2 X4.9141 Y-1.6679 I-0.3574 J0.1136
G1 X4.9035 Y-1.697
G2 X4.8981 Y-1.7112 I-0.3525 J0.128
G1 X4.8861 Y-1.7403
G2 X4.8805 Y-1.7534 I-0.347 J0.1422
G1 X4.8672 Y-1.7826
G2 X4.861 Y-1.7956 I-0.3413 J0.1553
G1 X4.8463 Y-1.8248
G2 X4.8396 Y-1.8375 I-0.3351 J0.1683
G1 X4.8236 Y-1.8666
G2 X4.8168 Y-1.8784 I-0.3284 J0.181
G1 X4.7994 Y-1.9075
G2 X4.792 Y-1.9193 I-0.3216 J0.1928
G1 X4.7731 Y-1.9483
G2 X4.7657 Y-1.9593 I-0.3142 J0.2046
G1 X4.7453 Y-1.9882
G2 X4.7378 Y-1.9986 I-0.3068 J0.2156
G1 X4.716 Y-2.0274
G2 X4.7083 Y-2.0373 I-0.2993 J0.226
G1 X4.6851 Y-2.0659
G2 X4.6773 Y-2.0753 I-0.2915 J0.2359
G1 X4.6527 Y-2.1037
G2 X4.6448 Y-2.1126 I-0.2837 J0.2452
G1 X4.6188 Y-2.1408
G2 X4.6106 Y-2.1494 I-0.2757 J0.2541
G1 X4.5831 Y-2.1773
G2 X4.5754 Y-2.185 I-0.2675 J0.2628
G1 X4.5467 Y-2.2126
G2 X4.5385 Y-2.2202 I-0.2598 J0.2704
G1 X4.5083 Y-2.2476
G2 X4.5003 Y-2.2546 I-0.2516 J0.278
G1 X4.4687 Y-2.2816
G2 X4.4608 Y-2.2881 I-0.2436 J0.2851
G1 X4.4279 Y-2.3147
G2 X4.4201 Y-2.3209 I-0.2357 J0.2916
G1 X4.3859 Y-2.3471
G2 X4.378 Y-2.353 I-0.228 J0.2977
X3.736 Y-2.6924 I-1.5121 J2.0836
G1 X3.6873 Y-2.711
G2 X3.678 Y-2.7142 I-0.1287 J0.3522
G1 X3.578 Y-2.7478
G2 X3.566 Y-2.7516 I-0.1194 J0.3555
G1 X3.4637 Y-2.7822
G2 X3.4521 Y-2.7854 I-0.1073 J0.3593
G1 X3.3479 Y-2.8129
G2 X3.3366 Y-2.8157 I-0.0957 J0.3626
G1 X3.231 Y-2.8401
G2 X3.2201 Y-2.8425 I-0.0844 J0.3654
G1 X3.1135 Y-2.8638
G2 X3.1029 Y-2.8657 I-0.0735 J0.3677
G1 X2.9957 Y-2.8839
G2 X2.9854 Y-2.8856 I-0.0628 J0.3697
G1 X2.8781 Y-2.9007
G2 X2.868 Y-2.902 I-0.0525 J0.3713
G1 X2.761 Y-2.9142
G2 X2.7512 Y-2.9152 I-0.0425 J0.3726
X1.8488 I-0.4513 J4.556
X1.839 Y-2.9142 I0.0327 J0.3736
G1 X1.732 Y-2.902
G2 X1.7219 Y-2.9007 I0.0425 J0.3726
G1 X1.6146 Y-2.8856
G2 X1.6043 Y-2.8839 I0.0525 J0.3713
G1 X1.4971 Y-2.8657
G2 X1.4865 Y-2.8638 I0.0628 J0.3697
G1 X1.3799 Y-2.8425
G2 X1.369 Y-2.8401 I0.0735 J0.3677
G1 X1.2634 Y-2.8157
G2 X1.2521 Y-2.8129 I0.0844 J0.3654
G1 X1.1479 Y-2.7854
G2 X1.1363 Y-2.7822 I0.0957 J0.3626
G1 X1.034 Y-2.7516
G2 X1.022 Y-2.7478 I0.1073 J0.3593
G1 X0.922 Y-2.7142
G2 X0.9127 Y-2.711 I0.1194 J0.3555
X0.257 Y-2.3793 I0.9056 J2.6047
X0.1799 Y-2.3209 I4.0764 J5.4593
X0.1721 Y-2.3147 I0.2279 J0.2978
G1 X0.1391 Y-2.2881
G2 X0.1312 Y-2.2815 I0.2358 J0.2916
G1 X0.0997 Y-2.2546
G2 X0.0917 Y-2.2475 I0.2437 J0.285
G1 X0.0615 Y-2.2202
G2 X0.0535 Y-2.2127 I0.2517 J0.278
G1 X0.0247 Y-2.1851
G2 X0.0167 Y-2.1772 I0.2597 J0.2705
G1 X-0.0107 Y-2.1493
G2 X-0.0187 Y-2.1408 I0.2677 J0.2626
G1 X-0.0447 Y-2.1126
G2 X-0.0527 Y-2.1037 I0.2757 J0.2542
G1 X-0.0773 Y-2.0753
G2 X-0.0851 Y-2.0659 I0.2836 J0.2453
G1 X-0.1083 Y-2.0373
G2 X-0.1161 Y-2.0274 I0.2915 J0.2359
G1 X-0.1378 Y-1.9986
G2 X-0.1454 Y-1.9881 I0.2993 J0.226
G1 X-0.1657 Y-1.9592
G2 X-0.1731 Y-1.9482 I0.3069 J0.2155
G1 X-0.192 Y-1.9192
G2 X-0.1992 Y-1.9077 I0.3143 J0.2045
G1 X-0.2167 Y-1.8786
G2 X-0.2236 Y-1.8666 I0.3215 J0.193
G1 X-0.2397 Y-1.8374
G2 X-0.2463 Y-1.8249 I0.3284 J0.181
G1 X-0.2609 Y-1.7957
G2 X-0.2672 Y-1.7827 I0.3351 J0.1684
G1 X-0.2804 Y-1.7535
G2 X-0.2863 Y-1.74 I0.3413 J0.1554
G1 X-0.2982 Y-1.7109
G2 X-0.3035 Y-1.697 I0.3471 J0.1419
G1 X-0.3141 Y-1.6679
G2 X-0.319 Y-1.6536 I0.3525 J0.128
G1 X-0.3282 Y-1.6247
G2 X-0.3325 Y-1.6101 I0.3573 J0.1137
G1 X-0.3404 Y-1.5812
G2 X-0.3442 Y-1.5663 I0.3617 J0.0991
G1 X-0.3508 Y-1.5376
G2 X-0.3539 Y-1.5224 I0.3654 J0.0842
G1 X-0.3593 Y-1.4939
G2 X-0.3618 Y-1.4786 I0.3686 J0.0691
G1 X-0.3659 Y-1.4502
G2 X-0.3678 Y-1.4348 I0.3711 J0.0538
G1 X-0.3707 Y-1.4066
G2 X-0.372 Y-1.3912 I0.373 J0.0384
G1 X-0.3737 Y-1.3633
G2 X-0.3744 Y-1.3479 I0.3743 J0.023
G1 X-0.3749 Y-1.3202
G2 Y-1.3048 I0.3749 J0.0077
G1 X-0.3744 Y-1.2771
G2 X-0.3737 Y-1.2617 I0.3749 J-0.0077
G1 X-0.372 Y-1.2338
G2 X-0.3707 Y-1.2184 I0.3743 J-0.023
G1 X-0.3678 Y-1.1902
G2 X-0.3659 Y-1.1748 I0.373 J-0.0384
G1 X-0.3618 Y-1.1464
G2 X-0.3593 Y-1.1311 I0.3711 J-0.0538
G1 X-0.3539 Y-1.1026
G2 X-0.3508 Y-1.0874 I0.3686 J-0.0691
G1 X-0.3442 Y-1.0587
G2 X-0.3404 Y-1.0438 I0.3654 J-0.0842
G1 X-0.3325 Y-1.0149
G2 X-0.3282 Y-1.0003 I0.3617 J-0.0991
G1 X-0.319 Y-0.9714
G2 X-0.3141 Y-0.9571 I0.3573 J-0.1137
G1 X-0.3035 Y-0.928
G2 X-0.2982 Y-0.9141 I0.3525 J-0.128
G1 X-0.2863 Y-0.885
G2 X-0.2804 Y-0.8715 I0.3471 J-0.1419
G1 X-0.2672 Y-0.8423
G2 X-0.2609 Y-0.8293 I0.3413 J-0.1554
G1 X-0.2463 Y-0.8001
G2 X-0.2397 Y-0.7876 I0.3351 J-0.1684
G1 X-0.2236 Y-0.7584
G2 X-0.2167 Y-0.7464 I0.3284 J-0.181
G1 X-0.1992 Y-0.7173
G2 X-0.192 Y-0.7058 I0.3215 J-0.193
G1 X-0.1731 Y-0.6768
G2 X-0.1657 Y-0.6658 I0.3143 J-0.2045
G1 X-0.1454 Y-0.6369
G2 X-0.1378 Y-0.6264 I0.3069 J-0.2155
G1 X-0.1161 Y-0.5976
G2 X-0.1083 Y-0.5877 I0.2993 J-0.226
G1 X-0.0851 Y-0.5591
G2 X-0.0773 Y-0.5497 I0.2915 J-0.2359
G1 X-0.0527 Y-0.5213
G2 X-0.0447 Y-0.5124 I0.2836 J-0.2453
G1 X-0.0187 Y-0.4842
G2 X-0.0107 Y-0.4757 I0.2757 J-0.2542
G1 X0.0167 Y-0.4478
G2 X0.0247 Y-0.4399 I0.2677 J-0.2626
G1 X0.0535 Y-0.4123
G2 X0.0615 Y-0.4048 I0.2597 J-0.2705
G1 X0.0917 Y-0.3775
G2 X0.0997 Y-0.3704 I0.2517 J-0.278
G1 X0.1312 Y-0.3435
G2 X0.1391 Y-0.3369 I0.2437 J-0.285
G1 X0.1721 Y-0.3103
G2 X0.1799 Y-0.3041 I0.2358 J-0.2916
X0.8641 Y0.0671 I1.5307 J-2.005
G1 X0.9127 Y0.086
G2 X0.922 Y0.0892 I0.1287 J-0.3522
G1 X1.022 Y0.1228
G2 X1.034 Y0.1266 I0.1194 J-0.3555
G1 X1.1363 Y0.1572
G2 X1.1479 Y0.1604 I0.1073 J-0.3593
G1 X1.2521 Y0.1879
G2 X1.2634 Y0.1907 I0.0957 J-0.3626
G1 X1.369 Y0.2151
G2 X1.3799 Y0.2175 I0.0844 J-0.3654
G1 X1.4865 Y0.2388
G2 X1.4971 Y0.2407 I0.0735 J-0.3677
G1 X1.6043 Y0.2589
G2 X1.6146 Y0.2606 I0.0628 J-0.3697
G1 X1.7219 Y0.2757
G2 X1.732 Y0.277 I0.0525 J-0.3713
G1 X1.839 Y0.2892
G2 X1.8488 Y0.2902 I0.0425 J-0.3726
X2.7512 I0.4513 J-4.5564
X2.761 Y0.2892 I-0.0327 J-0.3736
G1 X2.868 Y0.277
G2 X2.8781 Y0.2757 I-0.0425 J-0.3726
G1 X2.9854 Y0.2606
G2 X2.9957 Y0.2589 I-0.0525 J-0.3713
G1 X3.1029 Y0.2407
G2 X3.1135 Y0.2388 I-0.0628 J-0.3697
G1 X3.2201 Y0.2175
G2 X3.231 Y0.2151 I-0.0735 J-0.3677
G1 X3.3366 Y0.1907
G2 X3.3479 Y0.1879 I-0.0844 J-0.3654
G1 X3.4521 Y0.1604
G2 X3.4637 Y0.1572 I-0.0957 J-0.3626
G1 X3.566 Y0.1266
G2 X3.578 Y0.1228 I-0.1073 J-0.3593
G1 X3.678 Y0.0892
G2 X3.6873 Y0.086 I-0.1194 J-0.3555
X4.3429 Y-0.2456 I-0.9055 J-2.6046
G1 X4.378 Y-0.272
G2 X4.3859 Y-0.2779 I-0.22 J-0.3037
G1 X4.4201 Y-0.3041
G2 X4.4279 Y-0.3103 I-0.228 J-0.2977
G1 X4.4608 Y-0.3369
G2 X4.4687 Y-0.3434 I-0.2357 J-0.2916
G1 X4.5003 Y-0.3704
G2 X4.5083 Y-0.3774 I-0.2436 J-0.2851
G1 X4.5385 Y-0.4048
G2 X4.5467 Y-0.4124 I-0.2516 J-0.278
G1 X4.5754 Y-0.44
G2 X4.5831 Y-0.4477 I-0.2598 J-0.2704
G1 X4.6106 Y-0.4756
G2 X4.6188 Y-0.4842 I-0.2675 J-0.2628
G1 X4.6448 Y-0.5124
G2 X4.6527 Y-0.5213 I-0.2757 J-0.2541
G1 X4.6773 Y-0.5497
G2 X4.6851 Y-0.5591 I-0.2837 J-0.2452
G1 X4.7083 Y-0.5877
G2 X4.716 Y-0.5976 I-0.2915 J-0.2359
G1 X4.7378 Y-0.6264
G2 X4.7453 Y-0.6368 I-0.2993 J-0.226
G1 X4.7657 Y-0.6657
G2 X4.7731 Y-0.6767 I-0.3068 J-0.2156
G1 X4.792 Y-0.7057
G2 X4.7994 Y-0.7175 I-0.3142 J-0.2046
G1 X4.8168 Y-0.7466
G2 X4.8236 Y-0.7584 I-0.3216 J-0.1928
G1 X4.8396 Y-0.7875
G2 X4.8463 Y-0.8002 I-0.3284 J-0.181
G1 X4.861 Y-0.8294
G2 X4.8672 Y-0.8424 I-0.3351 J-0.1683
G1 X4.8805 Y-0.8716
G2 X4.8861 Y-0.8847 I-0.3413 J-0.1553
G1 X4.8981 Y-0.9138
G2 X4.9035 Y-0.928 I-0.347 J-0.1422
G1 X4.9141 Y-0.9571
G2 X4.919 Y-0.9714 I-0.3525 J-0.128
G1 X4.9282 Y-1.0004
G2 X4.9325 Y-1.0149 I-0.3574 J-0.1136
G1 X4.9404 Y-1.0437
G2 X4.9442 Y-1.0587 I-0.3617 J-0.0992
G1 X4.9508 Y-1.0875
G2 X4.9539 Y-1.1025 I-0.3654 J-0.0841
G1 X4.9593 Y-1.1311
G2 X4.9619 Y-1.1467 I-0.3686 J-0.0691
G1 X4.966 Y-1.1751
G2 X4.9678 Y-1.19 I-0.3712 J-0.0535
G1 X4.9707 Y-1.2182
G2 X4.972 Y-1.2336 I-0.373 J-0.0385
G1 X4.9737 Y-1.2616
G2 X4.9744 Y-1.2773 I-0.3743 J-0.0232
G1 X4.9749 Y-1.3051
X4.975 Y-1.3088
Y-1.3125
G3 X5.0145 Y-1.408 I0.135 J0. F200.
G1 G40 X5.064 Y-1.3585
G3.4 X5.1015 Y-1.321 Z-0.378
X5.1171 Y-1.3054 Z-0.325
G0 Z0.6
M9
G91 G28
M2
G28
G80
M61
M5
E

Message 6 of 10
seth.madore
in reply to: hkenuam

Oh, not the NC code, but the actual Fusion file.

File > Export > Save to local folder, return to thread and attach the .f3d/f3z file in your reply.

 

What post processor are you using?


Seth Madore
Customer Advocacy Manager - Manufacturing
Message 7 of 10
hkenuam
in reply to: seth.madore

Here ya go. 

 

Thanks in advance

Message 8 of 10
seth.madore
in reply to: hkenuam

Change your Tolerance on the 2D Contour toolpath, from .001" to .0001". Leave your Smoothing at .001".

These black dots represent toolpath points, Before and After:

Before.png

 

2023-02-19_14h16_16.png


Seth Madore
Customer Advocacy Manager - Manufacturing
Message 9 of 10
seth.madore
in reply to: hkenuam

Bulk of the resulting G-code:

N150 X5.064 Y-1.2665 Z-0.4
N155 G41 X5.0145 Y-1.217 D19
N160 G3 X4.975 Y-1.3125 I0.0955 J-0.0955
N165 G1 Y-1.3168
N170 G2 X4.7928 Y-1.9163 I-1.117 J0.0119
N175 X4.4418 Y-2.3025 I-1.2735 J0.8048
N180 X3.899 Y-2.6259 I-1.431 J1.7847
N185 X3.1067 Y-2.8642 I-1.3752 J3.1364
N190 X1.1982 Y-2.8001 I-0.808 J4.3902
N195 X0.4924 Y-2.5258 I0.8542 J3.2426
N200 X0.0201 Y-2.1818 I1.0561 J1.9464
N205 X-0.2857 Y-1.7439 I1.0182 J1.0368
N210 X-0.353 Y-1.0949 I1.0077 J0.4325
N215 X-0.0786 Y-0.5526 I1.2062 J-0.2698
N220 X0.3309 Y-0.1976 I1.3305 J-1.1213
N225 X0.9177 Y0.0868 I1.4316 J-2.2056
N230 X1.9034 Y0.2944 I1.2836 J-3.6525
N235 X3.4307 Y0.1673 I0.4026 J-4.4031
N240 X4.132 Y-0.1127 I-0.8647 J-3.1841
N245 X4.5817 Y-0.445 I-1.0703 J-1.9188
N250 X4.8855 Y-0.8808 I-1.017 J-1.0329
N255 X4.9755 Y-1.3125 I-1.045 J-0.443
N260 G1 X4.9757 Y-1.3213 F200.

Seth Madore
Customer Advocacy Manager - Manufacturing
Message 10 of 10
hkenuam
in reply to: seth.madore

Well, the most certainly made it much better. The rest might be feeds and speeds related. Thanks so much for the help. Fusion360 rocks!

 

hkenuam_0-1676847223175.png

 

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Post to forums  

Autodesk Design & Make Report