@allanpoole
I have looked at your file and done a couple of example toolpaths, a 3D Adaptive with a 1/4in End mill to rough it out and a Parallel with a 1/8in Ball End mill to get the shape as close as possible, at 100in/min feedrate your small model takes around 4 Hours to machine so a 24in square is likely to take a lot longer although you should be able to use a larger tool for the Roughing.
However, the closer that you want the finished shape to be to the Model will depend on two things, one is the smallest "valley" that you need to get into and the amount of stepover you need for best finish, the smaller the stepover the better the finish but the longer it will take to machine.
I have no idea how good your machine is so can`t give you any help with Feeds/Speeds etc, when doing this type of 3D machining the Z Axis will be doing a tremendous amount of movement to follow the shape, so if it is Stepper Motors then they may not be up to the task and you may ned to slow everything down if you get problems,the attached file is just an example of how it can be done.
Another thing that can be an issue is the time it takes to generate these large type of toolpaths, all depends on how powerful your computer is 🙂 🙂 🙂
The first image below shows the Roughing and the Finishing shapes, the second image shows the Finishing Parallel toolpath following the Model shape, hope this is of some use to you if only to point to possible types of toolpaths that could be used 🙂 🙂 🙂
For what it`s worth I would go back to the start and scale the Original Model to the size that you want 🙂
Rough is Green-Finish is Blue
