Is There a Way to Specify Tangency Direction/Side in Sketches?

Is There a Way to Specify Tangency Direction/Side in Sketches?

Simon_Fr
Explorer Explorer
227 Views
3 Replies
Message 1 of 4

Is There a Way to Specify Tangency Direction/Side in Sketches?

Simon_Fr
Explorer
Explorer

I have a question regarding the sketch shown in the images.

The two lines (marked in red) are constrained with tangency to one of the circles (marked in purple). However, if tangency is the only constraint applied to the lines, they could just as well be tangent to the opposite side of the circle. This implies that the sketch has multiple valid solutions (four when considering just those two lines).

 

From my observation, Fusion resolves this by selecting the first valid solution it encounters—typically depending on the initial position of the line. For example, if a line is closer to the bottom of the circle, it becomes tangent on that side, and vice versa.

As a sidenote, if the vertical line is also taken into account, the number of possible solutions increases further (up to eight in total).

 

I understand that this situation can be fully defined using additional constraints, and that there are workarounds to avoid the ambiguity. However, my intention here is mainly to highlight this behavior and better understand the underlying logic. I have included images showing two of the eight possible solutions for illustration.

 

Would it be possible or beneficial to have an additional constraint or option that explicitly defines on which side of the circle the tangency should be applied?

Thank you in advance for any insights!

 

Solution 1:

Simon_Fr_0-1777835175795.png

 

Solution 2:

Simon_Fr_1-1777836010521.png

 

0 Likes
228 Views
3 Replies
Replies (3)
Message 2 of 4

kacper.suchomski
Mentor
Mentor

Hi

This isn't possible. You need to create a sketch relatively close to the target geometry and then add the appropriate constraints.


Kacper Suchomski

EESignature


YouTube - Inventor tutorials | LinkedIn | Instagram

Did you find this post helpful? Feel free to Like this post.
Did your question get successfully answered? Then click on the ACCEPT SOLUTION button.


Message 3 of 4

Simon_Fr
Explorer
Explorer

Hi,

Thanks for your reply.

I’m aware of that approach, and my original intention was indeed to find a way to fully define the sketch using additional constraints. However, while working through this, I noticed the ambiguity in the tangency behavior and wanted to better understand how Fusion resolves it—and whether there might be room for a more explicit constraint option in such cases.

Appreciate your input!

0 Likes
Message 4 of 4

pkomatlapalli
Community Manager
Community Manager

Hi @Simon_Fr ,

I wanted to check in and see if you still needed assistance, or if you found a solution to your question already? Let us know if you need further assistance by providing an update or if you have found a solution, please share it with the community so other members who may have the same question could learn from your experience.

All the best,

Pavan Kumar | Community Manager

Pavan Kumar | Community Manager
0 Likes