Crease Edge in TSplines results in Box model?

cekuhnen
Mentor
Mentor

Crease Edge in TSplines results in Box model?

cekuhnen
Mentor
Mentor

So I select an Edge apply the crease command and the complete model is in box mode ?!

 

What am I doing wrong here?

 

crease.jpg

Claas Kuhnen

Faculty Industrial Design – Wayne State Universit

Chair Interior Design – Wayne State University

Owner studioKuhnen – product : interface : design

0 Likes
Reply
1,258 Views
13 Replies
Replies (13)

deyop
Alumni
Alumni

Anytime you try to crease an edge that ends in a star point it will change the model into box mode.  It doesn't know how to resolve a smooth shape from it.  It is a limitation in the T-Splines currently.  We have people working on a solution to the problem.  Another way to address the problem would be to add edges in the vicinity of the edge which don't end in a star point.  This will give you some control of the shape in that area.NotCrease.png

0 Likes

cekuhnen
Mentor
Mentor

Hi Deyop,

 

thanks for pointing this out. I was not aware of that creasing with star points currently do not work. I assumed creasing was working in general.

 

In addition to the current dev is it possible to have different level of creasing? Currently it looks Fusion only supports full or no crease!

 

Adding extra loop cuts of course also works just makes the mesh often so much more denser.

 

Pixar released their last code for subduvision surfaces to the public and it allows perfect edge creasing without the need of extra loopcuts to prevent edge crease artifacts.

 

 

Best


Claas

Claas Kuhnen

Faculty Industrial Design – Wayne State Universit

Chair Interior Design – Wayne State University

Owner studioKuhnen – product : interface : design

0 Likes

colin.smith
Alumni
Alumni

Hi Class,

 

You are correct that we currently only have options for full creasing  or no creasing.  In an upcoming release we will have levels of creasing to choose from.

 

Cheers,

 

Colin

 

 

 

 

Colin Smith
Sr. Product Manager
SketchBook
Alias Create VR (aka Project Sugarhill)
Automotive & Conceptual Design Group
0 Likes

tom.finnigan
Alumni
Alumni

@cekuhnen wrote:

Pixar released their last code for subduvision surfaces to the public and it allows perfect edge creasing without the need of extra loopcuts to prevent edge crease artifacts.


Hi Claas,

 

So I have taken a look at the pixar method for semi-sharp creasing, and it looks like it is unfortunately not directly applicable.  Specifically, using their method is great for rendering to the screen, but if you were to directly convert it to a NURBS then it would subdivide many times near the semi-sharp creases, doing more and more the tighter the radius is.  This is kind of a blocker for us, since we assume that pretty much every T-spline will eventually be converted to NURBS.

 

We might be able to approximate the surface near the creases so we don't have so many small patches, or come up with another semi-sharp scheme that is more NURBS-friendly.. either way, it is more complex than just dropping in the OpenSubdiv code, unfortunately.

 

This is not to say that we have given up on creasing - we know it is a high priority, and something that the t-splines team is working on.

 

- Tom


Tom Finnigan
Software Architect
1 Like

cekuhnen
Mentor
Mentor

Hello Tom,

 

 

that is too bad. The way how I worked around this was  in my 3D application to bake the model into a finer polygon mesh so the density better reflects the individually creased edges. This worked sufficiently in many cases.

 

Right with T-Spline in Fusion adding more loopcuts can of course also work. It makes the mesh more denser but it works.

Claas Kuhnen

Faculty Industrial Design – Wayne State Universit

Chair Interior Design – Wayne State University

Owner studioKuhnen – product : interface : design

0 Likes

deyop
Alumni
Alumni

Another way to manage the amount of creasing is to modify the tangent handles that are added whenever a crease is applied to edges.  Here is an video describing the concept.

 

Managing the tangent handle position will allow you to vary the angle between the two sides of the creased edge which will vary the sharpness of the crease.

0 Likes

cekuhnen
Mentor
Mentor

@colin.smith

 

Hey what happened to crease weights?

4 years past 😉

Claas Kuhnen

Faculty Industrial Design – Wayne State Universit

Chair Interior Design – Wayne State University

Owner studioKuhnen – product : interface : design

0 Likes

SaeedHamza
Advisor
Advisor

@cekuhnen

Wow, was there really such a limitation ... strange 😕

Anyway I guess it has been solved at some point, because it's working fine with me

 

Regards

 

Crease.png

0 Likes

SaeedHamza
Advisor
Advisor

This post is ANCIENT!

Post of the first men in Fusion Smiley Very Happy

0 Likes

cekuhnen
Mentor
Mentor

@SaeedHamza

 

Yes that works - I pinged Colin to know what happened about selective edge creasing.

T-Splines currently only offers no or full crease.

Claas Kuhnen

Faculty Industrial Design – Wayne State Universit

Chair Interior Design – Wayne State University

Owner studioKuhnen – product : interface : design

0 Likes

SaeedHamza
Advisor
Advisor

I see. That concept of the handles for a crease would be great to have

0 Likes

cekuhnen
Mentor
Mentor
yeah hence my question about what happened

this is 4 years back

Claas Kuhnen

Faculty Industrial Design – Wayne State Universit

Chair Interior Design – Wayne State University

Owner studioKuhnen – product : interface : design

0 Likes

cekuhnen
Mentor
Mentor
yeah hence my question about what happened

this is 4 years back

Claas Kuhnen

Faculty Industrial Design – Wayne State Universit

Chair Interior Design – Wayne State University

Owner studioKuhnen – product : interface : design

0 Likes