Announcements
Visit Fusion 360 Feedback Hub, the great way to connect to our Product, UX, and Research teams. See you there!
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

ESC to stop current calcualtion

ESC to stop current calcualtion

certain tasks and designs can freeze up Fusion as a user you do not know if it locked-up or will be responsive minutes later.

 

as a designer I rather instead of waiting and hoping want to press ESC and stop the current calcualtion.

48 Comments
cekuhnen
Mentor

@Anonymous

 

I agree that it can be annoying how ESC works.

 

Like in insert mesh ESC does not cancel the move you currently do it cancels to complete insert command.

In the browser when in a sketch clicking on a lightbulb in object to show/hide something with esc it reverts the visibility setting.

 

Somewhat inconsistent approaches - we are also talking about three very different scenarios I think.

Anonymous
Not applicable

Accepted, however I do not believe we are not so much "talking about three different scenarios" but more, I believe, we are talking about the underlying cause experienced in three different scenarios.

 

Open any browser. Do something, press the escape key and see what happens?  Ah, nothing (as expected).  Open any program and do the same.  Press alt.ctrl.del and try to end a task (this one may be one of the exceptions, but only depending on the program it is trying to force close) - very few will respond to such action on behalf of the user.  This is not so much a Fusion360 thing albeit they can fix it if they doctor the windows crap we get lumbered with or put out the resources to create their own code to get away from the (often) faulty C++ or suchlike generic code routines.

 

Decades ago I was writing programs for micros (Intel 8085's, 6802's, 6500's, z80's etc) and the program code had to be right otherwise it would not work.  Period.  I had never heard of Forth, Cobol, Pascal etc nor never needed to use them.  I was writing a program for a specific purpose and there was ONLY the user, no sockets for networks, now Google, no uplinking, nothing more than perhaps simple serial interface.

 

CAD is complex, very very complex.  It would make an accountants relationship database look like a kids broken toy.  HOWEVER, under any circumstances, there is no excuse for "excluding" the user from any programattical function or activity be it in this screen, or that screen or this or that function.

 

I have programmed, I have used many programs (as we all do) and I have wanted to throw the *king computer against the wall (as we all do) many a time.  Prodigies that write programs need to firstly understand the real world before imposing it on the world.

 

Like I said - can't press the emergency stop because I am currently cutting your hand off.

 

Sorry for all that, but this is one issue that pains me time and time and time again and every bit of software I get does the same thing over and over and over again.  When will people learn!

haughec
Autodesk

We agree, and have been working on providing the ability to interrupt compute.  Unfortunately, it's proven to be a rather large task.  We're implementing some core framework changes that should make this possible, but we're not yet close enough to provide a date.  Moving this to Future Consideration while the work continues.

 

Thanks,

Charles

haughec
Autodesk
Status changed to: Gathering Support
 
cekuhnen
Mentor

@haughec Thanks!

Anonymous
Not applicable

 

A lot of times can happen that a user enters an incorrect command, for example making a radius much bigger than possible, or presspulling a face that involving a much older operation in history time, and the program take a while to make that operation and often the result is a crash, is it possible to add a function that stops the current operation, pressing an escape button, and go back to the workspace, it should be useful and less annoying.

 

Many thanks for your work.
Alberto

Tags (3)
haughec
Autodesk

We agree, and have been working on providing the ability to interrupt compute.  Unfortunately, it's proven to be a rather large task.  We're implementing some core framework changes that should make this possible, but we're not yet close enough to provide a date.  Moving this to Future Consideration while the work continues.

 

Thanks,

Charles

haughec
Autodesk
Status changed to: Future Consideration
 
Anonymous
Not applicable

With each new version (and I've been using Fusion for close to 2 years) this is becoming more and more important.  At some point it seems it would make sense to halt some other efforts until this is fixed.  I think we're getting there.

roberto
Enthusiast

Hi, I'd like to hear about the progress one this one 🙂
It is still annoying as hell, yesterday I lost many hours waiting for operations to finish which I noticed would fail (because they take a very long time).

Kevin Schneider (I cannot tag you for some reason), you mentioned this was up for mid 2015 🙂

It would of course also be nice to have a progress bar while long calculations are happening.

roberto
Enthusiast

I have the same suggestion with lots of votes.
It would be good to get a refresh on this idea.

maritza.ga
Alumni

Hello all, 

Happy to share that this project is currently in progress and can be expected in an upcoming release. 

 

Maritza Garcia

Fusion 360 Experience Design 

maritza.ga
Alumni
Status changed to: オートデスク審査落選
 
roberto
Enthusiast

Awesome news @maritza.ga! Two plus years of waiting coming closer to reality!

So, who here is up for some champagne to celebrate?! 😛

 

keqingsong
Community Manager
Status changed to: Implemented

Thanks @keqingsong - that'll be a big help to a lot of people

Anonymous
Not applicable

Yes!  Been waiting for this a long time.

cekuhnen
Mentor

@keqingsong

 

Are you sure this applies to commands? In the post you reference to talk about ESC for the timeline.

I am talking about canceling time consuming modeling calculations where Fusion is sometimes working

for minutes which makes me simply force quite it.

Gah I didn't even look at the post. Assuming that's the case, my previous comment is retracted 😕

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Submit Idea  

Autodesk Design & Make Report