Question on the utilization of AGV elevators

Question on the utilization of AGV elevators

glenson_g
Not applicable
8 Views
6 Replies
Message 1 of 7

Question on the utilization of AGV elevators

glenson_g
Not applicable

[ FlexSim 18.2.3 ]

Hi @Felix Möhlmann ,

I used the state bar to observe the utilization of the elevators. I observed that when there is 16 AGVs, the utilization of the elevators at Core 3 (top right) is better than when there are more AGVs (i.e. 22, 20 or 18).

16 AGVs -
Lift A - 77.14%, Lift B - 71.41%, Lift C - 71.20%
compared to
22 AGVs -
Lift A -71.81%, Lift B - 67.85%, Lift C - 69.58%

Is it a correct phenomenon, or is there something wrong with my model/chart?

Also, in the chart, there is also a percentage for "Waiting". Is it a parameter that can be adjusted like the loading/unloading of AGVs or is it a fixed parameter?

Thank you!

liftusage_221106.fsm

0 Likes
Accepted solutions (1)
9 Views
6 Replies
Replies (6)
Message 2 of 7

moehlmann_fe
Observer
Observer
Accepted solution

When I run your model I am getting errors because you are trying to read from rows in the Origin Table that do not exist. You should probably fix this first before running experiments.

1667806791078.png

The "waiting" state is set in the "Open/Close Door Delay" activities in the elevator flow.

1667806865728.png

0 Likes
Message 3 of 7

glenson_g
Not applicable

Hi @Felix Möhlmann ,

I have fixed that error and have attached model here: liftusage-221106.fsm.

Still, is the phenomenon of the utilization of the lifts correct?

Got it for the "waiting" state. Thank you!

0 Likes
Message 4 of 7

moehlmann_fe
Observer
Observer

The error still happens. The maximum row value used when creating the tasks is 57. Currently the Origin Table only has 54 rows.

I would say the utilization values are correct. With more AGVs you more often have the case that once an elevator arrives at the ground floor another AGV will enter right away and be transported up, thus moving efficiently. With fewer AGVs, the same elevator might first travel back up empty to move another AGV down, before the next AGV arrives at the ground floor, increasing the overall travel distance and thus utilization.

As you can see below, the loaded travel distance and the loading/unloading times stay very similar, mostly just shift between the three elevators. While the travel empty duration increases, especially for lift A.

1667810046763.png

0 Likes
Message 5 of 7

glenson_g
Not applicable
Hi @Felix Möhlmann , just to check with you. How did you find the maximum row value used when creating the tasks to be 57?


I understood your reply for the utilization values. Thank you very much!

0 Likes
Message 6 of 7

moehlmann_fe
Observer
Observer

That is just the highest number I found assigned as the origin label in the source.

1667830736424.png

0 Likes
Message 7 of 7

glenson_g
Not applicable
Ah I see, thank you @Felix Möhlmann ! I will look into it.
0 Likes