Announcements
Autodesk Community will be read-only between April 26 and April 27 as we complete essential maintenance. We will remove this banner once completed. Thanks for your understanding

Community Redesign - Updates Since Launch

Platform-meeting-1310-2.jpg

A little over three weeks ago, we launched a major experiment on the forums - the first of its kindOur goal was to make resources easier to find, as well as improve navigation, accessibility, and enhance our mobile interface to create a more helpful, inclusive, and informative forums experience.  We understand that a change of this scale can take time to adjust to, and we have adopted an iterative and data-driven approach to continue refining the experience. This is just one part of the changes we have made and are continuing to make. You may have noticed a new Community Blog, Events, and Profile experience. Your engagement with these sections and the ways they’ve supported other community members have directly influenced the changes we’ve been making. Our community has grown quite a bit over the past few years, and this initiative is intended to help community members at all levels and stages in their professional journey.  

We’ve heard your feedback about the new forums design and recognize that some changes may feel disruptive, especially given how familiar many of you were with the previous design that had been in place for several years. Your input is invaluable to us, and we’re committed to addressing your concerns transparently. 

 

Why Did We Make These Changes? 

During our office hours, a community member shared, “My main interaction with Autodesk is using the software. Visiting the forums is secondary.” He explained that he often uses a search engine to find what he needs in community. If the link he clicks doesn’t give him the answers he is looking for, he goes back to search. We also learned that several community members heavily rely on notifications to keep track of the discussions they are part of. This reflects the experience of many of our community members. While these methods have been effective to an extent, they also highlight the data and feedback we have received, indicating that the current experience can be challenging to navigate and locate information. Community is where customers turn to when they have questions about using their software, want to learn about specific features or functions, share ideas about product improvements, or connect with other people who understand their challenges, frustrations and successes. However, how valuable is Community if this information is difficult to find or if key resources that could add value are missing?  

 As the Community grows and we introduce new products, the volume of information will increase, further compounding the challenge of finding helpful content. Recognizing the wealth of information and expertise our community members share every day, we wanted to make it easier to find and discover relevant content.   

 

Most Reported Concerns and Resolutions 

Our team has been collating your feedback, capturing your views and we have taken a data-driven approach to address your concerns. 

 

Trending Tab vs. All Tab 

  • Concern: Many of you expressed frustration with the "Trending" tab being the default, especially when revisiting a board multiple times a day. Many preferred seeing the "All" tab more frequently, to get a broader view of content.  
  • Resolution:  We’ve made the "All" tab the default because the way community members were engaging with it across all the boards consistently showed this was the preferred tab.  

Read vs. Unread Posts 

  • Concern: Many of you have also requested a clearer way to distinguish between read and unread posts.  
  • Resolution: We’ve partially resolved this issue and are working on a fix to better emphasize already-read topics with new replies for improved visibility.  

White Space 

  • Concern: There have been concerns regarding the dense spacing of the new forums, highlighting that it reduces usability. 
  • Resolution: To reiterate, we de-crowded the layout to enhance overall functionality, and balance accessibility by providing a more inclusive experience for our mobile community members and people with disabilities. The purpose of the white spacing was to reduce visual clutter, separate the elements, making content easier to read and process. However, we acknowledge your feedback and will have fixes to enhance specific sections over-impacted by this dense spacing by the end of next week.  

Pinned Posts 

  • Concern: There were also concerns regarding the visibility of pinned posts, making it difficult to locate important content. 
  • Resolution: We’ve improved the visibility of pinned post titles and have additional updates scheduled for next week to make these posts even more prominent. 

  

 Office Hours 

We are now hosting weekly office hours to provide you with a more direct way to voice your feedback and collaborate with the team that is driving these changes. These sessions are intended to be unstructured, open forums to provide space for you to discuss your thoughts with us. 

In our most recent session, held yesterday, we listened to your insights and are continuing to explore the following: 
 

  • Ability to switch off the experiment: While this option may not be implemented for the current experiment to ensure we reach statistical significance and maintain data integrity; we will consider incorporating this approach for future major iterations. 
  • “Back to topic listing” link at the bottom of long forum topic discussions: There are further opportunities to improve navigation and reduce scrolling time, these will be addressed in the future releases. 
  • Re-imagine the placements of the content sections: By the end of next week, we will have a fix to de-emphasize the “Trending topics and solutions” section based on engagement data.  
  • Ability to see subsequent pinned posts beyond the first one more clearly: More fixes are coming up regarding this concern. Stay tuned! 
  • Old events content: We recognize that some boards are displaying older event contents, and we are looking into a solution for this. 
  • Search on specific boards: Work is in progress to ensure that the search function defaults to only show content from the board from within which you are searching. 
  • Topic Tags: In the future, we will be implementing mandated & pre-defined topic tags to refine the tagging on community, making them for useful for content discoverability. 
  • Other: We also discussed difficulties finding created posts, labelling product versions, search improvements and more. 

Check out the recording of this office hours on its event page. We encourage you to join future sessions and share your thoughts. Thank you for your patience, collaboration, and continued engagement as we work toward making the community a better space for everyone! 

3 Comments
MartinBeh
Advisor

Not being able to filter out Read vs. Unread posts is a deal breaker. If nothing else get changed, please fix this one.

Alfred.NESWADBA
Consultant

Hi,

 

want to give some feedback to this article which in my opinion is very marketing oriented.

 

>> enhance our mobile interface

Please count the users of Autodesk's software, one one side working on mobiles and on the other side working on large size display or in most cases multiple displays. It's important to see that I guess 90% of the users searching in forums are working on large displays when they work with their software. Neither Revit, nor Inventor or AutoCAD will be used in most cases on mobiles. So why are you modifying a user interface for maybe 5 or 10% of the users? If you think it's important to have better layouts on mobiles then at least give the user the option to switch between 2 versions.

 

Additionally, the Autodesk forum is a technical driven forum, it is not Facebook, not X or any other of the social media text and image exchange platforms. These are more mobile device oriented platforms, understandable, but not a platform where we see screenshots (high res, not readable on a mobile device), sometimes videos, attached files and so on. Please start to recognize the difference!

 

>> we have adopted an iterative and data-driven approach

Well, if data is that important (which I agree, it is) why does exist another statement with "content older than 10 years will be removed"? For me old data is useful nowadays too, If it's any of your master products, all are older than 10 years and none of them had a real change or better a real break in their workflows. So answers valid 2010 are valid today too. Killing old data is not just losing valid data for forum search, but also losing a valid base for AI engines.

 

>> a community member shared

This is using marketing phrases, or even worse, phrases like politicians "I have spoken to a guy who suffers from ... and I'm the one who will solve that" ==> and like politicians ==> not any real sentence about what this solution is. Sorry for the wording, but that is how I interpret this "you have one community member ..."

 

>> how valuable is Community if this information is difficult to find

White space does not make an information easier to find. Contrary to this: if I get a list of threads which may contain my solutions, it's easier to go through a list line by line instead of having a list where each item has 3 lines and then much white space to the next line. In case of Excel and a list of persons: would you create a list with line 1 first name, line 2 last name, line 3 address, line 4 zipcode, line 5 country, or would you create 1 line and 5 columns? Each technician (which is the majority of your customers) will agree with 1 line, 5 columns, so why do we have a list of threads inside a forum with 3 lines per thread and then white space, so much that you even can't see more then 3 or 4 threads in the list, while you could see about 30 or 40 and therefor really the option to find the results faster?

 

>> we introduce new products, the volume of information will increase

This is an advantage, don't fight against it. Be happy you get such a mass of information via the forums. Other software vendors are happy with that kind of feedback!

 

>> Resolution:  We’ve made the "All" tab the default

You are mentioning this as advantage or solution? Sorry, but this would not have been to repaired if you would not have changed the previous layout. (that's also a point why I wrote "marketing wording")

 

>> more inclusive experience for our mobile community members

>> and people with disabilities

Great that you are thinking about people with disabilities!

However, as I wrote about mobile devices above I want to add: white space does not help, neither when looking at the site using a mobile device nor people with disabilities (which then have e.g. more stress because the need to scroll that much while they may have disabilities with their hands!)

 

>> The purpose of the white spacing was to reduce visual clutter,

>> separate the elements

Again, ask a technician about a list and how he/she wants to have it formatted. White space in a list of any type of items is a no-go. If it's a point list in Civil 3D, a BOM in Inventor or a door list in Revit, and the same counts for a forum list or search result list. Your thinking about CI and CD and layout should be adapt to your users, not the user should adapt to your thoughts about destructed lists with much white space and endless scrolling.

 

>> Ability to switch off the experiment:

My way (as developer), as long as a software is not ready, passed multiple tests, would be to first ask the user if he want's to be a beta tester. Your (Autodesk's) way to have not done the minimum tests and then let the user run into this untested environment is a no go for me. I can't let users run in such issues. Instead of finding an option for the user to turn this off you should turn off the experiment unless it is in a valid tested state. You may ask users if they want to run the tests for you, but it is not the job from your customer to spend his time and do the tests for Autodesk.

 

>> We encourage you to join future sessions

I would, if Autodesk first describes the reason of the change and what they will be improving compared to the current/older layout. If the wording again is to support better mobile devices, then it's senseless for me to spend time for these meetings.

 

BTW: this text box is not resizable, so all I see is just 5 lines, hard to select anything without losing the focused line, so please apologize issues in my text.

 

- alfred -

Cadguru42
Advisor

I was forced this morning to the new layout. How does adding more useless white space make it easier to read or parse the information? If I can't see the information because not enough is on the screen, then it's the opposite of making it easier to read. If it's for disability reasons, then give an option for the user to choose a disability version of the site. Or even just give the option for a mobile version versus a desktop version like most sites do.

 

The majority of Autodesk software runs on desktop computers. Why is there such a huge focus on making the technical product forums for desktop software look good on mobile devices (which I don't agree this does) at the expense of how they look on desktop browsers? Even this reply box can't be resized on desktop and I only see 5.5 lines.