@Neilw_05 wrote:
Are those arc slopes plus or minus? This what we get for feedback.
Neil, I'm sure that you understand it, but this how I would explain to those giving feedback.
"The grade shown is downhill in the direction indicated by the flow arrow.
Under this convention, Arrows never point uphill. Logically these downhill grades are all negative, but by convention they are unsigned. The direction is clarified by the arrow."
For a multi-segment polyline, the arrow and grade pair apply to the individual segment being labeled. C3D feature lines have a direction, from start to end as drawn. This direction can be reversed.
By default, C3D feature line segment grades are signed; positive is uphill in the feature line direction; negative is downhill in the feature line direction. Arrow point in the feature line direction. Visually, unless it is manually labeled with an arrow, there is no clear way to 'see' the feature line direction.
In the illustration below, the upper portion of the label shows the segment unsigned grade (drop negative) and the grade check value. Upper arrow rotation = grade check.
The lower portion of the label shows an unrotated arrow and signed grade.
This could be an alternate grading annotation convention.
Autodesk, at some point, stated including the grade check expression OOTB
Here is a similar illustration with the feature line direction reversed. Note that the arrow points downhill convention is consistent, but the feature line direction convention is different.
![2022-04-09 17_47_19-Autodesk Civil 3D 2022 - [feature line curve lables.dwg].png 2022-04-09 17_47_19-Autodesk Civil 3D 2022 - [feature line curve lables.dwg].png](https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/image/serverpage/image-id/1052971i405A22B0EBB79D47/image-size/large?v=v2&px=999)
Regarding "Conventions":
In the second episode of The Big Bang Theory, Penny is trying to convince Sheldon to throw Leonard a birthday party, after finding out his mother never threw him one as a child. She also tries to explain why he has to buy him a present. Sheldon just doesn’t get it, until Howard suggests that she should “Try telling him it’s a non-optional social convention”, which he immediately accepts.
Christopher Stevens
Did you find this post helpful? Feel free to Like this post.
Did your question get successfully answered? Then click on the ACCEPT SOLUTION button.
