Community
AutoCAD Forum
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

3d model solid editing

9 REPLIES 9
SOLVED
Reply
Message 1 of 10
coolkris
1120 Views, 9 Replies

3d model solid editing

coolkris
Advocate
Advocate

Dear all,

 

Help needed in 3d editing interference of 3d solid parapet walls as attached in image and cad files.

 

Thanks

 

Krish

0 Likes

3d model solid editing

Dear all,

 

Help needed in 3d editing interference of 3d solid parapet walls as attached in image and cad files.

 

Thanks

 

Krish

Labels (1)
9 REPLIES 9
Message 2 of 10
Valentin-WSP
in reply to: coolkris

Valentin-WSP
Mentor
Mentor

@coolkris ,

 

Use SUBTRACT to remove portion of one of the parapet. However, removing this portion will make the travel lane much narrower.  The best option is to rotate the single lane 3D object to avoid intersecting.

 

Reconsider redesigning.

 

ValentinWSP_0-1630062305102.png

 



Please select the "Accept as Solution" button if my post solves your issue or answers your question.


Emilio Valentin
0 Likes

@coolkris ,

 

Use SUBTRACT to remove portion of one of the parapet. However, removing this portion will make the travel lane much narrower.  The best option is to rotate the single lane 3D object to avoid intersecting.

 

Reconsider redesigning.

 

ValentinWSP_0-1630062305102.png

 



Please select the "Accept as Solution" button if my post solves your issue or answers your question.


Emilio Valentin
Message 3 of 10
coolkris
in reply to: Valentin-WSP

coolkris
Advocate
Advocate

thanks for suggestion. But this entrance ramp joining carriage way. So I need to trim both walls to make transition smooth. Can you please make screen shot of 2 steps to subtract. I am getting different results as attached.

 

Thanks

 

Krish

0 Likes

thanks for suggestion. But this entrance ramp joining carriage way. So I need to trim both walls to make transition smooth. Can you please make screen shot of 2 steps to subtract. I am getting different results as attached.

 

Thanks

 

Krish

Message 4 of 10
Valentin-WSP
in reply to: coolkris

Valentin-WSP
Mentor
Mentor

@coolkris ,

 

I rotated the instead of subtracting.  If you SUBTRACT, your results will not be smooth because of the elevation difference. You will have to determine where to begin/end the transition, so when they meet it is smooth.



Please select the "Accept as Solution" button if my post solves your issue or answers your question.


Emilio Valentin
0 Likes

@coolkris ,

 

I rotated the instead of subtracting.  If you SUBTRACT, your results will not be smooth because of the elevation difference. You will have to determine where to begin/end the transition, so when they meet it is smooth.



Please select the "Accept as Solution" button if my post solves your issue or answers your question.


Emilio Valentin
Message 5 of 10
Kent1Cooper
in reply to: coolkris

Kent1Cooper
Consultant
Consultant

Look into the SLICE command.

Kent1Cooper_0-1630069326766.png

 

Kent Cooper, AIA
0 Likes

Look into the SLICE command.

Kent1Cooper_0-1630069326766.png

 

Kent Cooper, AIA
Message 6 of 10
coolkris
in reply to: Kent1Cooper

coolkris
Advocate
Advocate

thanks for the reply It worked one side what about other side parapet wall to be trimmed without cutting deck slab.

Please find attached

Thanks

Krish

0 Likes

thanks for the reply It worked one side what about other side parapet wall to be trimmed without cutting deck slab.

Please find attached

Thanks

Krish

Message 7 of 10
Valentin-WSP
in reply to: coolkris

Valentin-WSP
Mentor
Mentor

@coolkris ,

 

Before slicing any objects, copy the 3D model to keep as original.  Then slice each side (like you did on the first one) from a copy and put it together.  However, this will give you an open section which you will need to fill (consider the LOFT command for that area) and make a solid.

 

ValentinWSP_0-1630075476716.png

ValentinWSP_1-1630075538919.png

 

 



Please select the "Accept as Solution" button if my post solves your issue or answers your question.


Emilio Valentin
0 Likes

@coolkris ,

 

Before slicing any objects, copy the 3D model to keep as original.  Then slice each side (like you did on the first one) from a copy and put it together.  However, this will give you an open section which you will need to fill (consider the LOFT command for that area) and make a solid.

 

ValentinWSP_0-1630075476716.png

ValentinWSP_1-1630075538919.png

 

 



Please select the "Accept as Solution" button if my post solves your issue or answers your question.


Emilio Valentin
Message 8 of 10
Kent1Cooper
in reply to: coolkris

Kent1Cooper
Consultant
Consultant
Accepted solution

For this result:

Kent1Cooper_0-1630078152750.png 

Kent1Cooper_0-1630079656923.png

I drew Lines [yellow] along straight edges through the intersection point:

Kent1Cooper_3-1630078732193.png

Flattened them down onto the XY plane and established the bisector angle between them [green]:

Kent1Cooper_2-1630078518351.png

Extruded that up into a Surface:

Kent1Cooper_1-1630078340927.png

And used corners of that in 3-point mode to SLICE each part, keeping the appropriate side in each Slice.

 

The road surfaces don't align exactly, but that's a different issue....

Kent Cooper, AIA

For this result:

Kent1Cooper_0-1630078152750.png 

Kent1Cooper_0-1630079656923.png

I drew Lines [yellow] along straight edges through the intersection point:

Kent1Cooper_3-1630078732193.png

Flattened them down onto the XY plane and established the bisector angle between them [green]:

Kent1Cooper_2-1630078518351.png

Extruded that up into a Surface:

Kent1Cooper_1-1630078340927.png

And used corners of that in 3-point mode to SLICE each part, keeping the appropriate side in each Slice.

 

The road surfaces don't align exactly, but that's a different issue....

Kent Cooper, AIA
Message 9 of 10
vinodkl
in reply to: coolkris

vinodkl
Mentor
Mentor

Hi @coolkris 

 

You can first use the command "INTERSECT" on both the solid to a final object something like this:

vinodkl_0-1630083430348.png

You can then copy this and paste it into a new drawing using the command "PASTEORIG". Now return back to your old drawing and undo(ctrl+z) the changes made by intersect command. Slice the parapet wall from both side and it will look like this.

vinodkl_1-1630083707346.png

Now copy the intersected portion from the new drawing and paste it into the old drawing using the command "PASTEORIG" which would look like this.

vinodkl_2-1630085919275.png

vinodkl_3-1630085954790.png

 

Now you can use the UNION command to combine all.

 

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ವಿನೋದ್ ಕೆ ಎಲ್( System Design Engineer)



Likes is much appreciated if the information I have shared is helpful to you and/or others.

Please mark "Accept as Solution" if my reply resolves the issue or answers your question, to help others in the community.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
0 Likes

Hi @coolkris 

 

You can first use the command "INTERSECT" on both the solid to a final object something like this:

vinodkl_0-1630083430348.png

You can then copy this and paste it into a new drawing using the command "PASTEORIG". Now return back to your old drawing and undo(ctrl+z) the changes made by intersect command. Slice the parapet wall from both side and it will look like this.

vinodkl_1-1630083707346.png

Now copy the intersected portion from the new drawing and paste it into the old drawing using the command "PASTEORIG" which would look like this.

vinodkl_2-1630085919275.png

vinodkl_3-1630085954790.png

 

Now you can use the UNION command to combine all.

 

 

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
ವಿನೋದ್ ಕೆ ಎಲ್( System Design Engineer)



Likes is much appreciated if the information I have shared is helpful to you and/or others.

Please mark "Accept as Solution" if my reply resolves the issue or answers your question, to help others in the community.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Message 10 of 10
coolkris
in reply to: Kent1Cooper

coolkris
Advocate
Advocate

Thanks a lot to all, this option seems to be the best.

 

Thanks

0 Likes

Thanks a lot to all, this option seems to be the best.

 

Thanks

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Post to forums  

AutoCAD Inside the Factory


Autodesk Design & Make Report