topic Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?) in Revit Architecture Forum

Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

ad.bognanno — Tue, 04 Apr 2023 14:47:58 GMT

Hello everyone,

I recently went onto Revit 2024 to see and test the new features.

After a few researches around the top ribbon, i couldnt find the "Building Pad" button to edit the fresh new Topography.

Now i hear the Topography in itself has changed to a solid, with thickness and other options.

Is the Building Pad gone for good, and if so, is there a clean alternative to it.

PS: im on Revit LT, no access to the void volumes..

Thanks for reading.

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

mhiserZFHXS — Tue, 04 Apr 2023 15:46:17 GMT

Does Revit LT not have these tools? Sorry, I haven't used it before.

Either way, it'd probably be best if they just made another dedicated tool for this. Building pads weren't perfect, but they kinda threw the baby out with the bathwater on this one.

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

ad.bognanno — Thu, 06 Apr 2023 07:35:42 GMT

No, sadly REVIT LT doesnt offer access to those tools.
Funny thing is : if you modify a file created on Revit LT 2023 WITH a building pad already inside it, you can modify it, and even create more occurencies.
A solution i consider is creating a template on 2023 with a simple building pad, then start from this for any 2024 projects and "abuse" this "feature".

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

constantin.stroescu — Thu, 06 Apr 2023 08:28:41 GMT

No more Building Pads...

but beside Mass Elements and Model in Place Families ( that are not available in LT) you ca use Walls, Floors and Roofs to Join with Toposolid. And , you can also create Void parametric Editable Families that can be used as Cut instrument...

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

ad.bognanno — Thu, 06 Apr 2023 14:00:51 GMT

I didnt think about the void families!
That may be a good workaround, i'll try that out soon.
Thanks for the answers

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

ToanDN — Sun, 09 Apr 2023 04:09:26 GMT

... until you need some odd shaped pads. Create in place model wall or in place model floor and model the void in it.

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

ross_karp — Mon, 10 Apr 2023 11:53:20 GMT

It was noted elsewhere that you can use shafts in LT and load parametric generic void families with instance parameters that can be stretched to shape etc

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

biztrobill — Mon, 10 Apr 2023 15:30:10 GMT

Hi @ad.bognanno

If you don't mind that the shaft tool cuts all the way through the toposolid, that's an easy option. I read that another option is to use the in-place wall tool, which can make a void. (I haven't tried it).

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

andersonreyesortiz — Thu, 13 Apr 2023 20:50:07 GMT

Hello there, i have created a Revit idea, asking for building pads come back.

Because there is no way to calculate cut and fills automatically. If you agree, please vote it here:

https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/revit-ideas/building-pads-on-revit-2024/idi-p/11892239

It is not a good idea creating in place components or mass family as an efective workflow.

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

ross_karp — Thu, 20 Apr 2023 21:16:49 GMT

you can control the bottom of the shaft i think

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

ToanDN — Thu, 20 Apr 2023 21:20:35 GMT

@ross_karp wrote:

you can control the bottom of the shaft i think

You can but a shaft will cut through the topo (or anything it touches) even if the bottom is above the bottom of the topo.

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

ross_karp — Thu, 20 Apr 2023 21:22:34 GMT

but it does cut right through even if you raise the shaft baSE

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

ross_karp — Thu, 20 Apr 2023 21:33:49 GMT

Also the pad had the ability to slope I think

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

ad.bognanno — Mon, 24 Apr 2023 14:43:28 GMT

Yes it did. I used pads to make a schedule of the "ground movements" , and the sloped pads helped a lot for this.

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

veso58S5W — Sat, 01 Jul 2023 23:10:08 GMT

Yes, that's the biggest minus. Right now, I use Revit24LT I have to create a solid (from Wall in Place) then modify bottom, to make the slope, just to find out I have to do that many times (curved driveways) in order to cut off from TopoSolid. Waste of time.

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

jche34 — Tue, 08 Aug 2023 22:31:28 GMT

I think Autodesk should just have left the toposurfaces in, with pads and everything - why not have both? I can see the benefits of the toposolids but surfaces have their advantages too - for one I've never been a fan of modifying sub elements on slabs which is the way you now edit the toposolids - annoying to say the least.... and yes, agreed, how are we supposed to do accurate cut/fill calculations? I see the voids do get subtracted out of the cut but to have the fill part added where the pad projects out of the ground I need to now create another solid and merge it? Double the work? Not sure what's going on... the old toposurface pads did both simultaneously.

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

cmilton — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 14:51:40 GMT

I tried void extrusions, modelled in place walls, floors and shafts. None of which cut a topo surface.

They have removed ALL the surface editing tools, not just pads. How can I cut my building out of my topo surface?

I can't even edit my surface points to "flatten" the area at the building. WTF!

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

blank... — Wed, 06 Sep 2023 18:28:33 GMT

@cmilton wrote:
I tried void extrusions, modelled in place walls, floors and shafts. None of which cut a topo surface.

You are definitely doing something wrong.

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

veso58S5W — Thu, 07 Sep 2023 23:54:11 GMT

I agree with @blank... must be something wrong you doing. Post a small test file.

Re: Revit 2024 - Building Pads (No more?)

wisedrawing — Fri, 08 Sep 2023 00:18:03 GMT

'Baby out with the bath water" is the perfect statement

We need them back

If a new tool is coming in, especially for LT, then add the new tools, but leave the old tool as an option, and educate for change through a transition period.

We have daily work processes that have been in place for years and you cant just take something out without affecting productivity and peoples livings.

even if a new tool is better, its takes time to transition to it and I have multiple projects on the go with 2023 and cant upgrade for fear of interrupting time constraints.

please put the Pads back!