topic Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder in Revit API Forum

Creating Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder based on slab sketch

andhxl — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 19:12:13 GMT

I need to create a Solid with a single PlanarFace using BRepBuilder.

A PlanarFace Edges based on a curves from sketch of a slab.

Below is the code of how I do it. I get the error "Autodesk.Revit.Exceptions.InvalidOperationException: 'BRep doesn't have enough faces.'" on brepBuilder.Finish();.

I do not understand how to create disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace (highlighted in red in the screenshot).

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

Mohamed_Arshad — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 13:14:27 GMT

Hi @andhxl

Do you need to project curve over the slab top surface ? Can you please explain in detail

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

jeremy_tammik — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 13:19:22 GMT

Maybe the BRepBuilderExample Revit SDK sample will help?

https://thebuildingcoder.typepad.com/blog/2017/05/revit-2017-and-2018-sdk-samples.html#4.4

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

andhxl — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 13:22:08 GMT

Hi, no, I need to get Solid with one PlanarFace. TessellatedShapeBuilder is not suitable for me, since I need not only Line, but also Arc and so on. Tessellation is not suitable

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

Mohamed_Arshad — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 13:25:33 GMT

Hi @andhxl

you need to create solid using one planar face correct ?

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

andhxl — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 19:48:46 GMT

Need Solid consisting of one PlanarFace, created by BRepBuilder.

This is how I get it using TessellatedShapeBuilder. I need the same thing, but without tessellation.

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

Mohamed_Arshad — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 14:16:57 GMT

HI @andhxl

I understand now, But you have created a TessellatedFace using single planar which a surface not solid. But we can't able to generate solid just using one planar face (Brep). You need thickness for that one. you can do one thing extract complete solid from the slab and and generate feature using DirectShape. Kindy check the below code.

foreach (GeometryObject geoObj in geoElement) { if (geoObj is Solid) { solid = geoObj as Solid; if (solid.Volume > 0) { break; } } } List<GeometryObject> objects = new List<GeometryObject>(); objects.Add(solid); using (Transaction createGometry = new Transaction(doc, "Create Disconnected Slab")) { createGometry.Start(); DirectShape directShape = DirectShape.CreateElement(doc, new ElementId(BuiltInCategory.OST_GenericModel)); directShape.AppendShape(objects); createGometry.Commit(); }

This is what we can do, Generating Solid using Face it possible, but you have to define some thickness to it.

Hope this will Helps 🙂

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

andhxl — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 14:18:01 GMT

No, that's not what I need. And we can create a Solid with one PlanarFace, I showed this code above with TessellatedShapeBuilder

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

Mohamed_Arshad — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 14:20:32 GMT

@jeremy_tammik @naveen.kumar.t @Moustafa_K

Can anyone help in solving this 🙂

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

Mohamed_Arshad — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 14:48:04 GMT

Hi @andhxl

Check the below workaround code
Reference Code

PlanarFace planarFace = null; foreach (GeometryObject geoObj in geoElement) { if (geoObj is Solid) { Solid solid = geoObj as Solid; if (solid.Volume > 0) { FaceArray faceArray = solid.Faces; foreach (Face face in faceArray) { if (face is PlanarFace) { PlanarFace pFace = face as PlanarFace; if (pFace.FaceNormal.Z == 1) { planarFace = pFace; break; } } } } } } List<GeometryObject> objects = new List<GeometryObject>(); using (Transaction createGometry = new Transaction(doc, "Create Surface Highlightes")) { createGometry.Start(); DirectShape directShape = DirectShape.CreateElement(doc, new ElementId(BuiltInCategory.OST_GenericModel)); objects.Add(ConvertPlanarFaceToSolid(planarFace)); directShape.AppendShape(objects); createGometry.Commit(); }

public Solid ConvertPlanarFaceToSolid(PlanarFace planarFace) { // Get the boundary edges of the planar face IList<CurveLoop> curveLoops = planarFace.GetEdgesAsCurveLoops(); // Get the normal direction of the face XYZ normal = planarFace.ComputeNormal(new UV(0.5, 0.5)); // Set the extrusion height to a very small value, making it a thin BRep double extrusionHeight = 0.001; // Create a solid by extruding the face along its normal direction Solid faceSolid = GeometryCreationUtilities.CreateExtrusionGeometry(curveLoops, normal, extrusionHeight); return faceSolid; }

Reference Video

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

andhxl — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 14:54:04 GMT

Need PlanarFace without any thickness(

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

jeremy_tammik — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 15:25:54 GMT

Did you look at the BRepBuilderExample Revit SDK sample, as suggested above? You didn't say anything about that:

https://thebuildingcoder.typepad.com/blog/2017/05/revit-2017-and-2018-sdk-samples.html#4.4

It includes a creation of a non-planar face, with no solid.

Please also take a look at the sample code in the documentation:

https://www.revitapidocs.com/2024/94c1fef4-2933-ce67-9c2d-361cbf8a42b4.htm

It demonstrates in detail the creation of faces, edges, coedges, including arcs.

Additional very helpful background information is provided by The Building Coder discussing BRepBuilder organisation:

https://thebuildingcoder.typepad.com/blog/2023/06/brepbuilder-and-toposurface-interior.html#2

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

ricaun — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 16:05:37 GMT

BRepBuilder can be tricky to work with, in your case you should change the BRepType.Solid to BRepType.OpenShell, this basically allow the builder to return a solid without a volume.

Sometimes the orientation matter, specially in the BRepType.Solid and BRepType.Void that you need to make sure all edges is register in the correct orientation.

Pretty sure if you change to BRepType.OpenShell your code gonna work fine.

Here is a full sample to copy a Face to Solid.

using Autodesk.Revit.Attributes; using Autodesk.Revit.DB; using Autodesk.Revit.UI; using System; namespace RevitAddin.Forum.Revit.Commands { [Transaction(TransactionMode.Manual)] public class CommandFaceToSolid : IExternalCommand { public Result Execute(ExternalCommandData commandData, ref string message, ElementSet elementSet) { UIApplication uiapp = commandData.Application; Document document = uiapp.ActiveUIDocument.Document; try { var faceReference = uiapp.ActiveUIDocument.Selection.PickObject(Autodesk.Revit.UI.Selection.ObjectType.Face); var element = document.GetElement(faceReference); var face = element.GetGeometryObjectFromReference(faceReference) as Face; var solid = CreateSolidFromFace(face); var normal = face.ComputeNormal(new UV(0.5, 0.5)); using (Transaction transaction = new Transaction(document)) { transaction.Start("Create Solid"); var ds = DirectShape.CreateElement(document, new ElementId(BuiltInCategory.OST_GenericModel)); ds.SetName(ds.Category.Name); ds.SetShape(new[] { solid }); ds.Location.Move(normal); transaction.Commit(); } } catch (Exception ex) { Console.WriteLine(ex); } return Result.Succeeded; } private Solid CreateSolidFromFace(Face face) { var surface = face.GetSurface(); var brepBuilder = new BRepBuilder(BRepType.OpenShell); var faceIsReversed = !face.OrientationMatchesSurfaceOrientation; BRepBuilderGeometryId faceId = brepBuilder.AddFace(BRepBuilderSurfaceGeometry.Create(surface, null), faceIsReversed); foreach (CurveLoop curveLoop in face.GetEdgesAsCurveLoops()) { BRepBuilderGeometryId loopId = brepBuilder.AddLoop(faceId); foreach (Curve curve in curveLoop) { var edge = BRepBuilderEdgeGeometry.Create(curve); BRepBuilderGeometryId edgeId = brepBuilder.AddEdge(edge); brepBuilder.AddCoEdge(loopId, edgeId, false); } brepBuilder.FinishLoop(loopId); } brepBuilder.SetFaceMaterialId(faceId, face.MaterialElementId); brepBuilder.FinishFace(faceId); brepBuilder.Finish(); return brepBuilder.GetResult(); } } }

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

andhxl — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 17:38:14 GMT

I looked, thanks. It became more clear. It especially helped to understand: https://thebuildingcoder.typepad.com/blog/2023/06/brepbuilder-and-toposurface-interior.html#2

Re: Creating disconnected Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder

andhxl — Thu, 19 Sep 2024 21:42:23 GMT

Thanks, I've tried with BRepType.OpenShell and I got an internal error. If you take the curves from Face, then it really works without problems. But if you get the curves from the slab sketch, then you need to determine whether they are reversed or not. The sketch could have been constructed any way. Now it is clear that it is possible to do this and that is the whole problem. It remains to understand how to accurately determine this

Re: Creating Solid with one PlanarFace using BRepBuilder based on slab sketch

andhxl — Fri, 20 Sep 2024 07:13:35 GMT

Thank you all! In the case of the sketch, I found this way out - combine several actions (creating Face and creating Solid based on it), to not care about the direction of the curves in the sketch:

Although, perhaps this can be done by creating a CurveLoop and determining the direction using IsCounterclockwise, without creating a temporary Solid