topic Re: IntersectWith command problem in .NET Forum

IntersectWith command problem

ekoneo — Sat, 16 Jul 2022 07:47:38 GMT

When I use IntersectWith command I am having problem.

Code is:

Point3dCollection ptColl = new Point3dCollection(); line.IntersectWith(pl2, Intersect.ExtendThis, ptColl, thisGraphicSystemMarker2, otherGraphicSystemMarker2); ed.WriteMessage("\n" + ptColl.Count);

However ptColl.Count gives 2 although there is only one intersection possiblity. What is the reason?

On the intersection point pl2 doesnt have any vertex.

Thanks.

Re: IntersectWith command problem

R.Gerritsen4967 — Sat, 16 Jul 2022 09:26:45 GMT

Maybe this is of some help...

To help troubleshooting, it might be helpful to write the coordinates of the points to the commandline. This way you can find out if they are the same.

Re: IntersectWith command problem

ekoneo — Sat, 16 Jul 2022 09:29:59 GMT

@R.Gerritsen4967 Really, exactly the problem is this. Thank you for your reply. I found the reason in the page:

"The code given above, when compiled, computes the intersection points and stores them in intPoints Points3DCollection. It is evident from the given geometry of both polylines that there should be a single point of intersection. On the contrary, the output returns two intersection points as shown below."

from: https://imrananees.blogspot.com/2021/02/analyzing-bug-in-intersectwith-autocad.html

Thank you.

Re: IntersectWith command problem

essam-salah — Sat, 16 Jul 2022 10:35:02 GMT

hi@ekoneo

so how did you recognize the fake intersection point from the true one ?

Re: IntersectWith command problem

ekoneo — Sat, 16 Jul 2022 10:49:12 GMT

@essam-salah hi.

It is a bit long solution but I get the right point. Only one of them is on the pl2. I prepare small for cycle including try catch end GetDistAtPoint function. GetDistAtPoint gives an "Autodesk.AutoCAD.Runtime.Exception" error. Via the error existance I can get the true point. When catch side working I deleted the point from the point collection. Sory for my bad English. I wish I could tell what I did.

Re: IntersectWith command problem

essam-salah — Sat, 16 Jul 2022 11:03:53 GMT

@ekoneo wrote:
@essam-salah hi.
It is a bit long solution but I get the right point. Only one of them is on the pl2. ..

@ekoneo

Cool, i hope autodesk solve the problem one day,

thanks for sharing.