topic Converting Inventor Part To Solid Works Shows Differences in Inventor Forum

Converting Inventor Part To Solid Works Shows Differences

t.beun — Wed, 29 Nov 2017 23:50:21 GMT

Hello everyone,

It seems to me that there are problems with converting an .ipt to a Solid Works part. Our manufacturer uses Solid Works. I send an .ipt to the manufacturer and they opened it in Solid Works. Solid Works showed differences between the Solid Works part and the Inventor part. Two holes had been disappeared, and 2 other holes where placed at the bottom at an angle. It seems to me that Solid Works is mistaking with workplanes or something like that. Is there anyone who has had this problem too? Why is Solid Works doing this? Is there a solution for it? What we do now is convert via a .STEP file.

Many thanks in advance for your replies!

Thomas

kelly.young has edited your subject line for clarity: Converting Inventor part to Soldi Works

Re: Converting Inventor Part To Solid Works Shows Differences

Thomas_Savage — Wed, 29 Nov 2017 23:50:41 GMT

Hello,

You can open Inventor files in solidworks, and it does recognize Inventor features.

But i usually save the .ipt as .Step or . iges files. To send to someone who uses Solidworks.

I think you could always get a few problems when opening an .ipt in another software.

Thomas.

Re: Converting Inventor Part To Solid Works Shows Differences

mcgyvr — Wed, 29 Nov 2017 23:50:57 GMT

@t.beun wrote:

Hello everyone,

It seems to me that there are problems with converting an .ipt to a Solid Works part. Our manufacturer uses Solid Works. I send an .ipt to the manufacturer and they opened it in Solid Works. Solid Works showed differences between the Solid Works part and the Inventor part. Two holes had been disappeared, and 2 other holes where placed at the bottom at an angle. It seems to me that Solid Works is mistaking with workplanes or something like that. Is there anyone who has had this problem too? Why is Solid Works doing this? Is there a solution for it? What we do now is convert via a .STEP file.

Many thanks in advance for your replies!

Thomas

Did you check with solidworks to see if the problem is because of their software?

Sounds like a problem you should be discussing with them..

But yes a step file is the best method to exchange 3d cad data to other software.. I'd suggest you keep doing that..

Re: Converting Inventor part to Soldi Works

Anonymous — Wed, 29 Nov 2017 15:37:53 GMT

Hello,

I maybe reply too late, but my answer can help the other readers of this post.

Datakit develops a plug-in to import inventor files in SolidWorks. It can have better results than the native Inventor import in SW.

Another solution is also to convert your ipt files to sldprt with CrossManager.

Take a look at this link to see more about the two solutions: http://www.datakit.com/cad-convertors/inventor-to-solidworks-3d/16-3-0.html

Re: Converting Inventor Part To Solid Works Shows Differences

JDMather — Wed, 29 Nov 2017 23:51:11 GMT

Can you attach an example *.ipt and resulting *.sldprt that exhibits this behavior?

Given that the native kernel for SolidWorks is Parasolid - I would probably save as *.x_b for transfer.