topic Re: Demote Component - Default File Location in Inventor Forum

Demote Component - Default File Location

andrewdroth — Wed, 06 Feb 2019 16:51:05 GMT

When I have a part(s) in an assembly that now needs to be a sub- assembly I RMB>Component>demote. Works great!

But the default file location is set the the last used. I would much prefer if it grabbed the location of the parent assembly. Is there any way to force this?

Re: Demote Component - Default File Location

JoyceZhou — Tue, 26 Feb 2019 09:48:38 GMT

Hi,

Have you active one Project? If yes, the default File location will be the Project path.

And if you have changed it to other location, it will remember to the last used location.

It seems your top assembly isn't in the last used location, and is it under the Project path?

Re: Demote Component - Default File Location

andrewdroth — Tue, 26 Feb 2019 14:52:45 GMT

We use Vault and one project file for ever job we do.

So it'll be C:\Designs\Projects\Project_Number

I might have six assemblies open at a time, and they may exist in separate organizational folders under the Project_Number folder.

But I want the Sub-Assembly I create to be in the same sub folder as the assembly it's being created in.

Re: Demote Component - Default File Location

andrewdroth — Sat, 09 Nov 2019 23:38:36 GMT

I've given this more though and it seems that the logical choice should be to default to the location of the assembly file the demote is being performed from?

It does not make any sense to default to the root of the project.

It should work like 'Make components" does in a part file where the default location is [Source Path]

Re: Demote Component - Default File Location

johnsonshiue — Mon, 11 Nov 2019 22:16:50 GMT

Hi Andrew,

This is a very good point! I agree that it should be defaulted to where the assembly file is located. Let me work with the project team to see what we can do.

Many thanks!

Re: Demote Component - Default File Location

sundars — Thu, 19 Dec 2019 00:55:37 GMT

Hi @andrewdroth

Thanks for pointing out this issue. @johnsonshiue and I spoke about this issue and we are happy to address this so that the default location will now set the location string in the dialog to be that of the original owning assembly. What you suggest makes sense.

For example if you have an assembly with the following structure

A1 (d:\temp)
+ S1 (d:\temp\Level1) <= level 1
+ P1 (d:\temp\Level1\Parts)

+ S2 (d:\temp\Level2) <= level 2
+ P1 (d:\temp\Level1\Parts)

+P2 (d:\temp\Level1\Parts)

Then

1. when you demote A1->S1->P1, the default location would be d:\temp\Level1 (S1's location)
2. when you demote A1->S2->P1, the default location would be d:\temp\Level2 (S2's location)

Note that Demote also supports multiple input selections. So when demoting

A1->S1->P1 and A1->S2->P2 we would have two different parents from two different locations. In that case, we have to choose S1 or S2's location - the rationale is to use the parent of the first selected component being demoted.

Selecting [P1, P2] -> would result in the default path being set to S1 location

Selecting [P2, P1] -> would result in the default path being set to S2 location

We have an internal defect created and we are working on it.

Thanks and let us know if you have any questions.

Best Regards,

-Shiva Sundaram

Re: Demote Component - Default File Location

andrewdroth — Thu, 19 Dec 2019 13:56:46 GMT

@sundars Thank You!

@sundars wrote:

Note that Demote also supports multiple input selections. So when demoting
A1->S1->P1 and A1->S2->P2 we would have two different parents from two different locations. In that case, we have to choose S1 or S2's location - the rationale is to use the parent of the first selected component being demoted.

I don't think I've ever tried demoting parts from different sub assemblies before. I think this logic makes sense.

Re: Demote Component - Default File Location

sundars — Thu, 19 Dec 2019 15:38:02 GMT

@andrewdroth Thanks for the confirmation - sometimes we like to over-engineer things to do complicated things which no one wants 🙂