topic Betreff: Roads error Infraworks in InfraWorks Forum

Roads error Infraworks

j.boon — Wed, 14 Apr 2021 06:40:38 GMT

Hi Autodesk community,

When I try to import a corridor from Civil3D to Infraworks, gaps show up between corridors. The gaps will disappear when the frequencies are modified in Civil3D. The frequencies are set to the absolute minimum which makes the drawing very hard to process for the computer. Is there any other way to make these little gaps disappear?

Thanks in advance!

Betreff: Roads error Infraworks

Karsten.Saenger — Wed, 14 Apr 2021 07:07:42 GMT

Hi @j.boon ,

are these gaps in the triangulation of the road terrain/surface?
You can check if you switch to the Engineering View.
If the gaps are in the triangulation, are you working witj large coordinates in Civil 3D?
Just for testing, what happens if you move the corridor in Civil 3D close to X,Y = 0,0 and import into InfraWorks then?

Regards,

Karsten.

Betreff: Roads error Infraworks

j.boon — Thu, 15 Apr 2021 08:43:51 GMT

Hi Karsten

The gaps are in the triangulation of the roadsurface.
I was working with large coordinates in Civil3D

The gaps remain in the corridors when I move them to 0.0.
I've also tried to manually add frequencies but that didn't completely solved the gaps.

Regards,

Jeroen

Betreff: Roads error Infraworks

Karsten.Saenger — Thu, 15 Apr 2021 09:38:29 GMT

Hi @j.boon ,

is it possible to share that Civil 3D sample DWG?

I'm wondering it it's an InfraWorks issue or a corridor surface creation issue in Civil 3D.
InfraWorks basically imports the Civil 3D corridor surface, so it could be that the triangulation issue happens in Civil 3D or while converting to IMX.
A quick test would be to export your DWG as IMX file, the re-import the IMX into a new DWG and check for the triangulation at the affected location.

Regards,

Karsten.

Betreff: Roads error Infraworks

j.boon — Mon, 19 Apr 2021 07:23:37 GMT

Hi Karsten

I'm currently working on the problem with Wojtek Garczewski. I have shared my file with him as it is not possible to publish this file "public". Thanks for your help!

Kind regards

Jeroen

Re: Roads error Infraworks

pieter_haeck — Mon, 12 Jul 2021 08:15:39 GMT

@Karsten.Saenger

@j.boon

Hello Karsten, Jeroen,
Do you have an update on this one (eventually from Wojtek as well)?

I have the same issue as Jeroen. Even when augmenting the frequency the results are not what to be expected:

The Corridor Surface on the contrary doesn't show any gaps:

Export/Import IMX of the Corridor Surface as the workflow you mentioned, results in the same: Surface without gaps.

It seems like IW is having issues with the treatment of assemblies with a depth/thickness:

All used subassemblies only have codes assigned to toplinks en top points, so it's strage IW creates 'vertical' geometry as shown above:

So, in my opinion, the only 'clean' workaround, is the 'old school' method: importing Corridor Surface as Terrain, and then using Coverages to apply materials.

Unless - as Jeroen stated - we are overlooking something 'obvious' 😉