topic Re: Redo button deletes geometry in Fusion Support Forum

Redo button deletes geometry

eerier_bleach0f — Mon, 22 Apr 2024 12:45:33 GMT

Add fillet > hit undo > decide I shouldn't have hit undo button so hit redo > fusion deletes geometry:

Here's 2 examples:

FileName: AddedFilletHitUndoRedo

Re: Redo button deletes geometry

jeff_strater — Mon, 22 Apr 2024 18:55:27 GMT

I apologize, but I do not see a problem from those videos. Undo and redo seem to be performing as I expect. Both start out with a model state where you are positioned in the middle of the undo stack. Redo can and should delete geometry, if that is the state that the model is in. You said that the sequence prior to this involves creating a fillet then deleting it. Can you illustrate that sequence? That is, show applying the fillet, then undo, then redo?

Re: Redo button deletes geometry

eerier_bleach0f — Mon, 22 Apr 2024 19:48:20 GMT

If I have this box:

And then I add a fillet to the top left edge, the model should look like this:

If I decide I shouldn't have added that fillet and I hit the "undo" button the model should look like this:

If I then decide I'm an idiot and I actually do in fact need the fillet, hitting the "redo" button should bring the fillet back and my model should look like this:

It shouldn't look like this:

Hitting "redo" should bring back the fillet, not delete faces.

You said that the sequence prior to this involves creating a fillet then deleting it.

I did not say this.

Redo can and should delete geometry, if that is the state that the model is in.

"I" am not deleting any geometry. All I am doing is creating a fillet and then hitting the "undo" and redo" buttons. Fusion is deleting geometry.

Re: Redo button deletes geometry

jeff_strater — Tue, 23 Apr 2024 00:17:22 GMT

that is not the experience that I see. Do you do something different in your example?:

(view in My Videos)

Re: Redo button deletes geometry

eerier_bleach0f — Tue, 23 Apr 2024 15:23:17 GMT

Great so in the video you just posted I see expected behaviour: You hitting the "redo" button reapplies the fillet and nothing more.

In my videos when I hit the "redo" button Fusion deletes faces:

I did not delete those faces. I need those faces. All I did was hit the "redo" button so I can bring my fillet back. But now I can peak inside my model.

Re: Redo button deletes geometry

jeff_strater — Thu, 25 Apr 2024 19:19:55 GMT

this feels like it is a graphics issue, not a geometry issue. It could be the graphics driver on your computer. I have not heard of anyone else seeing problems like you describe, which leads me to believe that this is not a general undo/redo geometry issue. Please feel free to share the design with me at jeff.strater@autodesk.com, if you would like. Preferably, share the model in a state before the fillet is applied.

Re: Redo button deletes geometry

eerier_bleach0f — Fri, 10 May 2024 13:41:18 GMT

This probably is a visual issue. Or a visual issue caused by another. I have a similar issue to this.

I pushed this face:

To be flush with the top like this:

Like in the image above it did what I wanted. But then I hit the "enter" key to apply the change. But it gave me an error and wouldn't make those faces flush. But after hitting "Enter" Fusion also removed the vertical faces like so:

And then I zoomed in and it brought the faces back.

Last week I completely wiped my computer and reinstalled the OS.

Sometimes like in the video above, hitting the undo button to revert back and then redo button brings the faces back, other's it does not.