topic Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020 in AutoCAD Forum

FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

mmiyamoto — Mon, 15 Apr 2019 23:15:01 GMT

I would like to see a 2020 version of this fix for Autocad based products. I currently use FBXIMPORT to bring 3d Revit models exported to FBX into Civil 3D.

https://knowledge.autodesk.com/support/autocad/troubleshooting/caas/sfdcarticles/sfdcarticles/FBXIMPORT-and-FBXEXPORT-removed-from-AutoCAD-2019.html

Thanks

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

natasha.l — Mon, 29 Apr 2019 16:50:08 GMT

Hello @mmiyamoto,

The export/import of FBX files has been removed from AutoCAD products & replaced with the import DWG option in Autodesk 3ds Max and other products that support FBX files. It is now recommended to use other products or AutoCAD versions like AutoCAD 2018 to convert to FBX.

Please "Accept Solution" if a reply or replies have helped resolve the issue or answered your question, to help others in the community.

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

Alfred.NESWADBA — Mon, 29 Apr 2019 19:30:54 GMT

Hi,

for AutoCAD 2019 there existed a plugin, I hope strongly that this will be updated for 2020!

This is one thread about that >>>click<<<

And here is the plugin for 2019 >>>click<<< (but I have not got it working with 2020, loading the ARX fails)

- alfred -

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

jhamilton — Wed, 15 May 2019 20:04:28 GMT

This is really not a good solution. We use fbx import all the time to bring in preliminary site models and vendor models into Autocad for use with plant 3d. Taking the imx from infraworks into Civil 3d just makes things so much more difficult to work with.

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

uriel.gomezLKYN7 — Fri, 14 Jun 2019 15:53:02 GMT

It's a so ban solution.

I think Autodesk should be provide solutions between his own software, not provide problems

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

skylardaniels — Tue, 03 Sep 2019 02:19:14 GMT

Below is a link to a Navisworks app that allows you to import objects directly from Navisworks to AutoCAD in real time. It makes referencing objects a Federated model relatively easy.

While it is currently not optimized for large exports (either a lot of objects, or very complicated object geometry), it will work. There are plans to add the ability to export a file out of Navisworks to disc, then import into AutoCAD in a future release which should hopefully make it more efficient for very large imports.

Navis To Acad

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

Alfred.NESWADBA — Tue, 03 Sep 2019 07:14:23 GMT

Hi,

>> a link to a Navisworks app that allows you to import

>> objects directly from Navisworks to AutoCAD

May I ask what this app has to do with the missing FBX-Import/-Export?

- alfred -

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

skylardaniels — Tue, 03 Sep 2019 18:37:00 GMT

Alfred,

I know I answered this in your personal post but I will go ahead and answer it here as well...

To give you some perspective on why it has replace FBX import/export for me, I am a tradesperson who does BIM VDC work fulltime for a contractor. I work primarily out of Navisworks (for coordination with other trades) and AutoCAD. We would regularly use FBX export from Navisworks in order scavenging design model valves/components/equipment/vessels/steel or any other model content that we were not provided in DWG form and import them into AutoCAD. I am not sure of your use of FBX other than to import to Civil 3D from infraworks, but when FBX import capabilities were removed it disrupted our workflow for accessing this geometry from Navisworks to AutoCAD. Could we manage to bring them in by converting the FBX to DWG with 3DS max? Sure, but it was not very streamline and if one did not have the AEC license bundle they would have to purchase additional software.

I hope that I did not offend anyone by posting this here, I just it might help some folks. Will Navis to Acad be beneficial in your personal workflow? Maybe. Could it benefit other folks who are using Navisworks along side AutoCAD who stumble upon this thread? I would bet on it.

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

jhamilton — Wed, 04 Sep 2019 11:45:56 GMT

I have had to resort to doing this. I have had mixed results with this. Normally when I use FBX it is to go to 3ds Max. The only time I do this to AutoCAD is to take models done in a 3rd party software like Tekla over to AutoCAD. I have had some occasions where the export from Navisworks will not open in AutoCAD.

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

stefanbaur6198 — Tue, 17 Dec 2019 16:21:32 GMT

I would like to see the FBX-Import and Export feature to come back to autocad2020 since the dwg-export from autocad to 3dsmax is buggy (it may be an error on my side).

As i have posted in this thread: https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/3ds-max-forum/importing-dwgs-from-autocad2020-to-3dsmax/td-p/9207340

the meshes are oddly subdivided and the uv's are messed up completly.

I tried different options when exporting (legacy, linking, sorting, etc...) but no luck yet.

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

pendean — Tue, 17 Dec 2019 19:47:44 GMT

You can tell Autodesk all about your ideas here where they pay attention to them, not in these forums https://www.autodesk.com/company/contact-us/product-feedback and https://www.augi.com/wish-list

Fingers Crossed!

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

stefanbaur6198 — Wed, 18 Dec 2019 07:34:28 GMT

Ok, i have made a request, but i doubt that they will bring back fbx. I guess this is a strategical move from autodesk. i can't figure out what they want to achieve with this strategy except annoying the customers.

I couldn't care less if the dwg-export would work as it should, but that is not the case or i am doing it wrong.

So if someone could show me how to get a clean mesh with a texture from Autocad to 3dsmax, that'll be great.

That is my problem and i would like to get it solved now. I can't wait and hope for Autodesk to bring back fbx sometime in the future, i need a solution.

I'm really thankful for future hints/workarounds/comments

Keep them coming

Cheers

Stefan

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

pendean — Wed, 18 Dec 2019 14:28:07 GMT

They did for 2019 when many folks asked.
YOU just need to ensure everyone you know does the same to bump up those stats.

Its hard work asking for what you want.

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

stefanbaur6198 — Wed, 18 Dec 2019 16:40:19 GMT

As i recall, Autodesk released it just for a short time and then deleted the fbx-plugin again. Luckily, users who got it could share the plugin with others.

But as i stated before, i don't have time for asking colleagues to make requests to autodesk and hope for the fbx-plugin.

All i want is someone to help me get the dwg-import from autocad to 3dsmax right. I mean, this should be doable. Am i asking too much, when i want to import a simple mesh with a texture.

Cheerio

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

stefanbaur6198 — Fri, 20 Dec 2019 08:21:07 GMT

I have found a solution for my specific problem with using plex in autocad and getting that terrain into max.

I posted it here:

https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/3ds-max-forum/importing-dwgs-from-autocad2020-to-3dsmax/m-p/9209991/highlight/false#M182053

Cheers

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

vaughan.giles7AGEV — Wed, 26 Feb 2020 01:27:01 GMT

The year is now 2020.... is there a solution to this problem?

...importing plain .imx data from Infraworks is insufficient and doesn't capture the likes of custom shapes and solids... therefore I am trying this ".fbx" alternative.... if only 2020 would actually have the feature to import said files.

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

pendean — Wed, 26 Feb 2020 13:43:16 GMT

Forgive me, but its already been state that "Autodesk removed the feature" so there is never going to be a fix from Autodesk for plain AutoCAD as discussed above https://forums.autodesk.com/t5/autocad-forum/fbximport-export-for-autocad-2020/m-p/8760167#M977903

You can tell Autodesk about your feelings here, if you and a 100000 other users do it there is a chance it might come back https://www.autodesk.com/company/contact-us/product-feedback

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

cborrero — Fri, 08 May 2020 23:30:14 GMT

NO SIRVE!!

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

jbokic2F9MM — Fri, 31 Jul 2020 17:49:52 GMT

Thanks pendean, I used the link.

We pay for the suite, and I don't have the time or inclination to learn another software suite just to get a command back that used to work. It's the same with ReCap and classifications in lidar, you used to be able to select only the classifications you wanted in Civil 3D and it would create the surface from it. Now they expect you to do that with another suite in the software. So now we get the GIS department to generate our EG surfaces for us.

If they keep this up, it may be worth only purchasing the individual software packages rather than the suite.

edit: it's almost like going back to the 90's where we needed to have 3rd party developers to provide the solutions we needed, but this time Autodesk did have them before and chose to remove them.

Re: FBXIMPORT/EXPORT for Autocad 2020

jhamilton — Tue, 04 Aug 2020 19:41:39 GMT

I totally agree this is a feature that needs to return in some fashion. There are many times we get models in from vendors that the only file format we could get to work successfully was an .fbx. I don't know why the feature was removed from 2020, but we really need it back in 2021 and beyond.