Discussion Groups

Simulation Mechanical and Multiphysics

Reply
Member
bend
Posts: 3
Registered: ‎10-26-2011

Lift and Drag Force Calculation

2293 Views, 12 Replies
10-26-2011 02:57 PM

Hi. I am trying to perform a simple Lift and Drag Force calculation on a aerofoil. Are the steps I have followed correct:

 

1. Loaded an Inventor model of a simple aerofoil into the Steady State Fluid Flow environment.

2. Created an external fluid surrounding the aerofoil, essentially a large box.

3. Meshed the model.

4. Added a nodal velocity to the 'front' surface of the box to simulate the freestream.

5. Added a inlet/outlet condition to the 'back' surface of the box to simulate the exit.

6. Set the Material for the fluid to air, and suppressed the model of the aerofoil itself.

7. Run the Simulation 

 

 

Now everything seems to have worked to this point. To find the Lift force and Drag Force I am a bit more sketchy, this is what I have done

8. Selected the Reaction Force in the Z direction to be displayed from the REsults Contours Menu (This is for Lift, for Drag I would select Y direction)

9. Selected the surfaces from the Air Part model that surround the aerofoil (essentially all surfaces except the box boundaries, and the 'Interior Surfaces'), and then asked to select nodes as subentities.

10. Clicked on "inquire Results", and "Sum" to give me the total force in the relevent direction (force in Z direction for Lift force, and force in Y direction for Drag force).

 

Is this correct? Because my drag force seems to be very very small (e-7 N!) and I do not trust this

Please use plain text.
Employee
Joey.X
Posts: 259
Registered: ‎06-14-2010

Re: Lift and Drag Force Calculation

10-27-2011 01:49 PM in reply to: bend

The word airfoil usually indicates 2-D planar, so if you want performing Lift and Drag Force calculation on an airfoil, 2-D planar simulation will simplify your workflow. 3D simulation is for plane, wing or other 3D objects. Anyway, it's some fashion of waste in computational resource and setup time to do airfoil in full 3D simulation. But it is still good to go if you set it up correct (see next).

 

Be careful doing the 2-D case in 3D simulation, especially in result evaluation. First, the experimental result (or your comparison result) for airfoil has assumption of infinite depth, or depth effect needs to be ignored. However, in your 3D box, you do always have front and back walls and which impacts the flow patterns, this applies to the top and bottom walls, so you should have reasonable offset for this effect, this is called wall effect in experimental aerodynamics. 

 

To get the total drag and lift force from FEA analysis, only select the nodes on the airfoil surfaces(Don't select  any other nodes) , then you can do any summation on x,y,z directions.

Also notes the reaction force counts the pressure (normal to airfoil surface) and shear stress (tangential to airfoil surface due to velocity gradient and fluid viscosity).

 



Jianhui Xie, Ph.D
Principal Engineer
MFG-Digital Simulation
Please use plain text.
Member
bend
Posts: 3
Registered: ‎10-26-2011

Re: Lift and Drag Force Calculation

10-27-2011 02:40 PM in reply to: bend

Ok- clarification I was using 3d elements as I was modelling a wing, whose profile is obviously an aerofoil.

 

So in summary the steps I was following are correct? As in I just select the surfaces that make up the surface of the aerofoil/wing itself and sum in the 'up' direction for 'Lift' and the Left/Right direction for drag?

 

Cheers

Ben

Please use plain text.
Employee
Joey.X
Posts: 259
Registered: ‎06-14-2010

Re: Lift and Drag Force Calculation

10-27-2011 06:01 PM in reply to: bend

Ben,

Your steps are correct :-), but as said before, the result accuracy could be skeptical, which depends on your model setup of the box, the wall effect is one of the factor. 

And again, if you are doing wing which has different airfoil profiles in wing's aspect direction(wing's root to tip), the 3-D modeling is necessary. If the airfoil profile keeps same in wing's aspect direction, I would suggest to do 2D planar simulation which is much cheaper and avoids the issue the wall effect in depth direction.  It sounds your case is in second category according to your most recent reply,  I am just trying remind that the wall(front and back) effect in 3D modeling  is probably not trivial depending your enclosure box setup.

 

Jianhui Xie, Ph.D
Principal Engineer
MFG-Digital Simulation
Please use plain text.
Employee
INACTIVE_AstroJohn
Posts: 492
Registered: ‎03-25-2010

Re: Lift and Drag Force Calculation

10-27-2011 07:22 PM in reply to: Joey.X

Here is something else to check. It doesn't occur very often, but I have seen it happen before. Is the size of the model correct in Autodesk Simulation? For example, you expect the wing to be 60 m long, but in the model it somehow turned out to be 60 mm long?

 

The only other factor that comes to mind is the air density. Depending on what units are shown, the density could be in units that are unfamiliar and/or difficult to work with. In this type of situation, expand the "Unit System" branch in the browser (near the top) and activate one that is more comfortable to use. For example, either SI so that the density is in kg/m^3, or whatever the english system is that uses lbm/in^3.

 

 

Sincerely,
John Holtz, P.E.
Senior User Experience Designer, Simulation
Autodesk, Inc.

Current version of Mechanical & Multiphysics: 2013 SP1 (2013.01.00.0012 28-Jun-2012)
Please use plain text.
Employee
Joey.X
Posts: 259
Registered: ‎06-14-2010

Re: Lift and Drag Force Calculation

10-31-2011 02:16 PM in reply to: INACTIVE_AstroJohn



FYI, Attached a simple 2D fluid flow model which demonstrates the lift/drag force calculation. 

------

attachment

------

- Full pre-defined model (2200_2Dsubm_10deg_un.zip)

- Simple description/result (.pdf)

- Pressure animation (2200_2Dsubm_10deg_un_pressure.zip)

  (download and unzip it to .mp4 to play animation) 

 

------

Note

------

- 2D sub moving at speed of 8.3ft/s, attack angle 10 degree

- 2D planar unsteady fluid flow analysis

- Symmetric BC at top and bottom boundaries 

- Water 

- Model geometry imported from CAD

- Results include velocity, pressure, flow rate and  reaction force, you have to re-run the model to get all results I deleted all result because of the upload size limitation

 

Unzip attached .zip file to open Autodesk simulation Multiphysics, click "Run analysis" you will get all result.

Jianhui Xie, Ph.D
Principal Engineer
MFG-Digital Simulation
Please use plain text.
Employee
Joey.X
Posts: 259
Registered: ‎06-14-2010

Re: Lift and Drag Force Calculation

10-31-2011 02:17 PM in reply to: Joey.X

Missed attachment for last post

Jianhui Xie, Ph.D
Principal Engineer
MFG-Digital Simulation
Please use plain text.
Member
bend
Posts: 3
Registered: ‎10-26-2011

Re: Lift and Drag Force Calculation

11-01-2011 02:45 PM in reply to: bend

Thanks Joey.

 

I seem to be getting better results now after remeshing the model with a finer mesh. Cheers. Ben

Please use plain text.
New Member
sbohnenberger
Posts: 1
Registered: ‎11-06-2011

Re: Lift and Drag Force Calculation

11-08-2011 12:44 AM in reply to: bend

Does someone have a 3d version example of a wing simulation in a windtunnel? I am working on something like this but I can't make it.

 

Thanks for any response.

Please use plain text.
Employee
Joey.X
Posts: 259
Registered: ‎06-14-2010

Re: Lift and Drag Force Calculation

11-08-2011 07:37 AM in reply to: sbohnenberger

Post two pictures for 2D airfoil in 3D modeling by one layer element in depth direction.

 

 

(2) It is perfered to setup 2D planar model for airfoil. (See my previous post and example model in this thread)

 

 

 

From pressure pattern, one can image the the lift and drag force directions.

pressure pattern 

Jianhui Xie, Ph.D
Principal Engineer
MFG-Digital Simulation
Please use plain text.