Revit MEP

Reply
Valued Contributor
88 Posts
15 Kudos
Registered: ‎01-04-2012
Post 1 of 4

out of the box generic pipe elbows

787 Views, 3 Replies
10-28-2012 02:39 AM

Perhaps someone can explain to me on why the out of the box generic welded elbows aren't as customizable as they should be?  If the elbow is 90 degrees, it appears to be a short radius elbow.  However, if the elbow is acute (less than 90 degrees), the elbow has a longer turn radius.  It also appears to have a varying turn radius as the angle changes --- which I don't really understand.  I've had to copy/paste/modify the out of the box family to get elbows with a turn radius that can be controlled by user (instance parameter) and change a few other parameters.

 

It's not something new, but I've never really understood this.

 

Comparison.jpg

OOTB Family.jpg

Modified Family.jpg

 

 

 

      

Active Contributor
36 Posts
3 Kudos
Registered: ‎02-23-2011
Post 2 of 4

Re: out of the box generic pipe elbows

10-28-2012 05:18 PM in reply to: Sandleaz
Architects designed the mechanical systems and the various bits and pieces. The why I have never understood, either. Sent from my iPad
Valued Contributor
59 Posts
1 Kudo
Registered: ‎02-28-2008
Post 3 of 4

Re: out of the box generic pipe elbows

10-29-2012 08:10 AM in reply to: sforsberg215

I posted something similar to this, a few weeks ago.  I noticed some of the PVC drain elbows had a different sweep at certain sizes.  The problem is in the out-of-the-box look-up tables.  I had suspected that other families had this problem as well.  I had to modify the look-up table and distribute that to my users.  That complicates the software mantenance process.  I will have to look into your solution. 

Valued Contributor
88 Posts
15 Kudos
Registered: ‎01-04-2012
Post 4 of 4

Re: out of the box generic pipe elbows

10-31-2012 08:11 AM in reply to: RandMan

The problem is in the out-of-the-box look-up tables.  I had suspected that other families had this problem as well.  I had to modify the look-up table and distribute that to my users.

 

I am not sure it's the data in the look up tables that is incorrect --- or at least that's not the only thing.  The fitting outer diameter values in the look up table are close to REVIT's default values for a schedule 40 carbon steel pipe.  The formula for the turning radius varies with the angle.  This occurs with the default pvc elbow as well.

 

x-look up table comparison.jpg 

 

x-schedule 40 carbon steel.jpg

 

x-socketed pvc elbow.jpg

 

 

 

   

Post to the Community

Have questions about Autodesk products? Ask the community.

New Post
Announcements
Are you interested in helping shape the future of the Autodesk Community? To participate in this brief usability study, please click here. Your time and input is greatly appreciated!