Revit Architecture Forum
Welcome to Autodesk’s Revit Architecture Forums. Share your knowledge, ask questions, and explore popular Revit Architecture topics.
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Inventor Vs Revit

14 REPLIES 14
Reply
Message 1 of 15
dvanerem
2771 Views, 14 Replies

Inventor Vs Revit

The company I work for is trying to decide whether to go to Inventor or Revit. We are a high end architectural millwork company which only does the engineering. I have experience in Inventor but practically none in Revit. Our AutoCAD drawings get very detailed and I am worried that Revit will not be able to give all the detail we need in the millwork. Any advice or past experiences would be greatly appreciated.

Dustin VanErem

PS I have attached a somewhat typical drawing of the detal that we need. It can get much more detailed than this.
14 REPLIES 14
Message 2 of 15
Anonymous
in reply to: dvanerem

No, not Revit for these drawings. I would suggest to stick to Acad and learn
the new 2007 3d capabilities for your 3d details.
Message 3 of 15
Anonymous
in reply to: dvanerem

I disagree. I think Inventor would be a great solution. Especially if you
have lots of standard profiles, cabinet types and things that you do over
and over. Inventor would also be a great communication tool for working with
clients.

"JTB" wrote in message
news:5237435@discussion.autodesk.com...
No, not Revit for these drawings. I would suggest to stick to Acad and learn
the new 2007 3d capabilities for your 3d details.
Message 4 of 15
JeffreyMcGrew
in reply to: dvanerem

I second that. I'm in both camps. My day job is helping a big firm use Revit. My night job is running my own business that makes furniture, custom interiors, and more using a CNC milling table in conjunction with Revit and other 3d tools.

While you can go from Revit to a CNC table, and for certain jobs there is a lot of value there (it rocks for doing custom interiors) there's a lot of stuff lacking (it's not so hot for custom furniture).

Revit's always working in the context that you're putting a building or interior together; not an assembly of complex, interrelated, solid parts that make up something like a chair. That's Inventor's realm. And while I'm not using Inventor, I am learning a different MCAD parametric system just so that we can make certain things we do easier and faster. Revit's also not well suited to quickly modeling complex, sculptural, organic shapes. That's Max's realm. And again, I don't use Max, I use a different 3D program for that work, and then export those models to the CNC mill too.

The big thing that's really lacking from Revit is the ability to 'explode' or break down your model into it's individual parts quickly on a small scale. Also I've found it's modeling toolset to not be as strong in that area, making small, curvy, assembly-based models or complex, organic, fluid models will take a lot longer in Revit then in another tool. Great for buildings, great for generating plans, sections, elevations, etc. It would make a very nice layout tool for your cabinets, actually, and would let you do custom interiors like nothing else. But fabrication models, of complex cabinets? You could do it, but you'd be better off doing it in Inventor. It's got stronger modeling tools for small parts, and it does a lot of things that help you then manage and break down your product into it's individual parts for actual fabrication.

As for using the new AutoCAD, well, while it's modeling has gotten better recently, it still doesn't NOTHING to help you manage your complex models, to handle changes for you parametrically, or to take your models and quickly turn them into a set of drawings. And while it's now got a lofting tool, it still doesn't come close to the kind of organic modeling a 'real' 3D system like Max lets you do. If your crew knows AutoCAD, and refuses to learn new tools, then sure it's a good solution. But there's a lot of value to be had in these other tools, so if you think you can leverage it I think you'll find that Inventor might be your best choice (if you wanna stay with Autodesk that is, which it sounds like you do).
Message 5 of 15
Anonymous
in reply to: dvanerem

Inventor is a manufacturing solution, which is what you're doing. Revit is a
building modeling solution. Go with Inventor.

--

Matt Dillon
Autodesk Architectural Desktop Certified Expert

View my ADT Blog "Breaking Down the Walls" at
http://www.modocrmadt.blogspot.com

wrote in message news:5237341@discussion.autodesk.com...
The company I work for is trying to decide whether to go to Inventor or
Revit. We are a high end architectural millwork company which only does the
engineering. I have experience in Inventor but practically none in Revit.
Our AutoCAD drawings get very detailed and I am worried that Revit will not
be able to give all the detail we need in the millwork. Any advice or past
experiences would be greatly appreciated.

Dustin VanErem

PS I have attached a somewhat typical drawing of the det
al that we need. It can get much more detailed than this.
Message 6 of 15
Anonymous
in reply to: dvanerem

Is Inventor based on a platform similar to Revit?
Or "something completely different" as they say?



"Matt Dillon" wrote in message
news:5237806@discussion.autodesk.com...
Inventor is a manufacturing solution, which is what you're doing. Revit is a
building modeling solution. Go with Inventor.

--

Matt Dillon
Autodesk Architectural Desktop Certified Expert

View my ADT Blog "Breaking Down the Walls" at
http://www.modocrmadt.blogspot.com

wrote in message news:5237341@discussion.autodesk.com...
The company I work for is trying to decide whether to go to Inventor or
Revit. We are a high end architectural millwork company which only does the
engineering. I have experience in Inventor but practically none in Revit.
Our AutoCAD drawings get very detailed and I am worried that Revit will not
be able to give all the detail we need in the millwork. Any advice or past
experiences would be greatly appreciated.

Dustin VanErem

PS I have attached a somewhat typical drawing of the det
al that we need. It can get much more detailed than this.
Message 7 of 15
JeffreyMcGrew
in reply to: dvanerem

Yes and no.

Inventor and Revit share no code as far as I know, and both use different modeling engines to do what they do.

However, the original team that came up with Revit came from a company that made a competitor to Inventor, and you can see a lot of similar ideas carried over from that tool into Revit.

So... they are distant cousins, more or less.
Message 8 of 15
Anonymous
in reply to: dvanerem

Something completely different, but similar in some ways.

Inventor was developed from the beginning by Autodesk. Revit was acquired by
Autodesk. That's the primary difference, aside from the target market. Their
similarities are in the concept of how they address their specific
disciplines.

However Inventor is a parametric, rules-driven application for the
manufacturing industry, and Revit is the same for the building industry. The
requirements of the two disciplines are vastly different, and so are the
solutions that address those requirements.

--

Matt Dillon
Autodesk Architectural Desktop Certified Expert

View my ADT Blog "Breaking Down the Walls" at
http://www.modocrmadt.blogspot.com

"david" wrote in message
news:5237919@discussion.autodesk.com...
Is Inventor based on a platform similar to Revit?
Or "something completely different" as they say?



"Matt Dillon" wrote in message
news:5237806@discussion.autodesk.com...
Inventor is a manufacturing solution, which is what you're doing. Revit is a
building modeling solution. Go with Inventor.

--

Matt Dillon
Autodesk Architectural Desktop Certified Expert

View my ADT Blog "Breaking Down the Walls" at
http://www.modocrmadt.blogspot.com

wrote in message news:5237341@discussion.autodesk.com...
The company I work for is trying to decide whether to go to Inventor or
Revit. We are a high end architectural millwork company which only does the
engineering. I have experience in Inventor but practically none in Revit.
Our AutoCAD drawings get very detailed and I am worried that Revit will not
be able to give all the detail we need in the millwork. Any advice or past
experiences would be greatly appreciated.

Dustin VanErem

PS I have attached a somewhat typical drawing of the det
al that we need. It can get much more detailed than this.
Message 9 of 15
Anonymous
in reply to: dvanerem

how does it compare with something like SolidWorks?
or what would be a rival software?


wrote in message news:5237341@discussion.autodesk.com...
The company I work for is trying to decide whether to go to Inventor or
Revit. We are a high end architectural millwork company which only does the
engineering. I have experience in Inventor but practically none in Revit.
Our AutoCAD drawings get very detailed and I am worried that Revit will not
be able to give all the detail we need in the millwork. Any advice or past
experiences would be greatly appreciated.

Dustin VanErem

PS I have attached a somewhat typical drawing of the det
al that we need. It can get much more detailed than this.
Message 10 of 15
Jeffreymcgrew
in reply to: dvanerem

Do you mean how does Revit compare to Solidworks? It doesn't. Just like with Inventor, it's a totally different market. Inventor and Solidworks are direct competitors, they are both manufacturing solutions.

If you mean what's a rival to Revit, well, the only thing IMHO is ArchiCAD... and even then the two are so different in some ways that it's a stretch to say even that.
Message 11 of 15
Anonymous
in reply to: dvanerem

Actually I meant how does Inventor compare to Solidworks. I understand
Solidworks to have a major foothold in my area and I was wondering how
Autodesk's product rates in comparison.



wrote in message news:5238482@discussion.autodesk.com...
Do you mean how does Revit compare to Solidworks? It doesn't. Just like with
Inventor, it's a totally different market. Inventor and Solidworks are
direct competitors, they are both manufacturing solutions.

If you mean what's a rival to Revit, well, the only thing IMHO is
ArchiCAD... and even then the two are so different in some ways that it's a
stretch to say even that.
Message 12 of 15
JeffreyMcGrew
in reply to: dvanerem

Wrong place to ask. No one here probably can help you out. Go over to the Inventor forum, or try to talk to some local shops and get demos of both.

Inventor isn't used much in the AEC market as far as I know, it's as Matt says, a manufacturing tool instead, so it's used a lot by the companies that make the products that we then take and use in buildings by re-drawing them in Revit. 😉

Jeffrey
Message 13 of 15
Anonymous
in reply to: dvanerem

I'll certainly check the Inventor forum....just thought I'd ask the question
since the software was being discussed.


wrote in message news:5239085@discussion.autodesk.com...
Wrong place to ask. No one here probably can help you out. Go over to the
Inventor forum, or try to talk to some local shops and get demos of both.

Inventor isn't used much in the AEC market as far as I know, it's as Matt
says, a manufacturing tool instead, so it's used a lot by the companies that
make the products that we then take and use in buildings by re-drawing them
in Revit. 😉

Jeffrey
Message 14 of 15
revitpilipinas
in reply to: dvanerem

hi, i think you should go for inventor since that is the core of your firm
Message 15 of 15
Revitstudent
in reply to: dvanerem

i am a high school student studying autoCAD, Revit and inventor. from what i can see by your drawings, which are very detailed like you said, i would have to say inventor, i have worked with both revit for modeling and inventor and i like inventor for objects much bette

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Post to forums  

Autodesk Design & Make Report


Autodesk Design & Make Report