Community
Inventor Forum
Welcome to Autodesk’s Inventor Forums. Share your knowledge, ask questions, and explore popular Inventor topics.
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

what is this error???? and why happend ?

24 REPLIES 24
Reply
Message 1 of 25
bms953
1489 Views, 24 Replies

what is this error???? and why happend ?

i create a part and use that as Drive part in some another part, when i want do anything like select Feature , create Sketch , adding Constraint , .... this error appear for me  (((( a Cyclical constraint dependency was detected ))))

 

i attached file

Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

24 REPLIES 24
Message 2 of 25
karthur1
in reply to: bms953

Can you post the Door Panel.ipt?

Message 3 of 25
bms953
in reply to: karthur1

tnx for respond

Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

Message 4 of 25
bms953
in reply to: bms953

any solution

Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

Message 5 of 25
hosford
in reply to: bms953

I didnt get the error you show.

Why are you using a sweep?

Thaddeus Hosford
NUC9i9QNX i9-9980HK, Win 10 Pro 64
Nvidia GTX 1650
Inventor 2021
Message 6 of 25
bms953
in reply to: hosford

sweep for create an edge around door , door has many part and every part is around main structure of door has this sweep

Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

Message 7 of 25
bms953
in reply to: hosford

do u can create a door Panel with Multi body from Drive part with out any error?

Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

Message 8 of 25
hosford
in reply to: bms953

Couldnt you just extrude the required lip?

 

Thaddeus Hosford
NUC9i9QNX i9-9980HK, Win 10 Pro 64
Nvidia GTX 1650
Inventor 2021
Message 9 of 25
bms953
in reply to: hosford

yes i can, but for extrude i should create some another rectangle in sketch , as well as my problem isn't Sweep or Extrude , problem is this error A Cyclical Constraint dependency was detected.

Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

Message 10 of 25
hosford
in reply to: bms953

ok, I have downloaded your models, played around in them, added extrusions, sketches, and cant get the error you have.

Do you get this error when trying to make a new sketch?

Thaddeus Hosford
NUC9i9QNX i9-9980HK, Win 10 Pro 64
Nvidia GTX 1650
Inventor 2021
Message 11 of 25
bms953
in reply to: hosford

any work, like this pic i attached , i want create an Extrude Cut and i have this error

Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

Message 12 of 25
hosford
in reply to: bms953

I dont know what to tell you.

have you rebooted since the problem accured?

see attached image.

Thaddeus Hosford
NUC9i9QNX i9-9980HK, Win 10 Pro 64
Nvidia GTX 1650
Inventor 2021
Message 13 of 25
bms953
in reply to: hosford

thank you very much for help to me, yes i have rebooted file and i still have this problem

Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

Message 14 of 25
bms953
in reply to: bms953

JDMather , karthur1 , DarrenP or any other Master on this forum, Help

 
Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

Message 15 of 25
karthur1
in reply to: bms953

I'm like the others that posted.  I don't see an error when I try to extrude cut either.  Can you zoom out just a little so we can see what you are picking when you extrude? 

 

I also tried to create a new door panel (new body) and did not get an error.

 

Are you using the latest SP1.1 update.  Not sure if it makes any difference.

 

2012-10-27_1822.png

Message 16 of 25
bms953
in reply to: karthur1

i reopen my file and when i want right click in design tree and delete some feature i have this error , i try to create this file again for 3 time but all of them have this problem, i just Install Inventor 2013 and i have not install SP 1.1

Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

Message 17 of 25
bms953
in reply to: karthur1

i download ur file and try to do something and i have not any error

Behzad Meskini

Competitor in World skills Competition 2005 Finland (Mech,Eng,CADD)
Member of Iranian Elite Foundation
Autodesk Certified Professional-AutoCAD
Autodesk Certified Professional-Inventor Pro
Autodesk Certified Professional-3ds Max
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Architecture
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit Structure
Autodesk Certified Professional-Revit MEP
DS CATIA Certified V5 Mechanical Surface Designer Specialist
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Part Design
DS CATIA Certified V5 Associate - Surface Design
DS Solidworks-CSWP-Mechanical Design Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Sheet Metal Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Weldments Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Surface Professional
DS Solidworks-CSWA-Advanced Drawing Professional

Message 18 of 25
JDMather
in reply to: bms953

If I were doing this model I think I would do as multi-body solids in a single part file and then push out the individual parts.

There appears to be total symmetry on my quick inspection that almost all the sketches (in the master file) can be simplified by half.

 

Notice that these areas do not automatically highlight for Extrude and the Sketch Doctor  - Red Cross appears in the Extrude dialog box.

 

I recomend simplyfing the sketch.

In my experience I will do parts of it on one side of the centerline and other parts on the other side trying to avoid overlap and no reason to duplicate work.

 

Sketch Doctor.png


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Autodesk Inventor 2019 Certified Professional
Autodesk AutoCAD 2013 Certified Professional
Certified SolidWorks Professional


The CADWhisperer YouTube Channel


EESignature

Message 19 of 25
JDMather
in reply to: JDMather

There seems (to me) to be an excessive number of geometry constraints in this sketch.

 

Excessive Constraints.png


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Autodesk Inventor 2019 Certified Professional
Autodesk AutoCAD 2013 Certified Professional
Certified SolidWorks Professional


The CADWhisperer YouTube Channel


EESignature

Message 20 of 25
JDMather
in reply to: JDMather

Running Sketch Doctor ( several times) I was partially able to fix the sketch, but not entirely.
I recommend starting over and no dulplication.

 

Partial Fix.png


-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Autodesk Inventor 2019 Certified Professional
Autodesk AutoCAD 2013 Certified Professional
Certified SolidWorks Professional


The CADWhisperer YouTube Channel


EESignature

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Post to forums  

Autodesk Design & Make Report