When is the functionality of generating a cut list from the multi body part file going to happen?
This is available in Solid Works and ver frastrating its not for Inventor.
I hope never.. SolidWorks uses multibody for its FG (weldments), Inventor uses assemblies, I think all cut lists should only be called off assemblies. For consistency accross all models, not just FG, it makes more sense for the way Inventor handles properties through the BOM. A multi-body part was never intended to be detailed, only the assembly pushed from the MB part.
Just my opinion but I am not trying to turn Inventor into SolidWorks and I don't expect SolidWorks to run like Inventor.
What about plate work?
Understand your point of view. But when using the multi body technique it is very difficult to provide an accurate BOM and also difficult to get ifeature properties into the generated parts. Also for e.g. if you have a structural member ifeature and extrude it between 2 faces, how do you get the length??
A reference dimension in a sketch can be used in the part files to pull through into the BOM for overall length.
Even though I would prefer to use assembly files, I would like to see options for sketch dimensions from the feature that created the solid (and possibly automated overall length) to be pulled through with the solid into the part files (not manually).
It was easier before multi-body when we used skeletal modelling because we had the sketch and the features in the part file. Now I generally use all reference sketches in the child parts and copy and paste formulas in the BOM. Combine this with input columns in the BOM for custom properties in the equations and you can set it up pretty quick. That said I will still allow at least half a day for the BOM/parts list when I quote for any pressure vessel.
You can manually pull through ifeature parameters but there is always room for improvement. Most of the time my ifeature would be detailed not listed in the parts list.
Something similar to the sheet metal overall size property would be a welcome inclusion for all parts.
Thanks Paul for the detailed info. I have raised this as an enhancement request with our development team for future release of Inventor.
Ah good. As long as I don't see the 3DS splash screen the first time I boot up Inventor 2014
Access a broad range of knowledge to help get the most out of your products and services.
Start with some of our most frequented solutions or visit the Installation and Licensing Forum to get help installing your software.
Upgrading to a 2015 product? Make sure to check these out 1st!