Vault IdeaStation
Share your wish list directly with the Autodesk Vault Development Team
New Idea
21 Kudos

Description

Navisworks if great for comparing a historical and current model. It is not possible to load historical revisions from models to compare them to each other. On this moment you need to models with different names/file type to compare them.

 

2014-07-30_15-04-27.png

 

 

Impact

Not having this feature has a significant impact on the process for comparing models during design phase, particularly one which has a somewhat complex or large modeling projects.

Due to this product limitation, it might actually put users off from using Vault in combination with Navisworks. 

Severity                                                  

Medium-High

 

Solution

Streamline the UI functionality between all Vault add-ins. The best example is AutoCAD with the ability to use shortcuts, saved searches from the dialog. And make it this way possible to use Revisions of a file to be loaded. By solving this the users know what to expect when opening files from Vault.

 

2014-07-30_15-08-00.png

 

2014-07-30_15-18-20.png

3 Kudos
douthett

Seeing which files need migrated in Vault

Status: New Idea
by Distinguished Contributor douthett on ‎11-14-2014 10:21 AM
Currently you have to download a file to your local and then do to Design Assistant or open it in Inventor to see if the file needs to be migrated. I would like the option to be able to see if the file needs migrate and what version it was last migrated to. By having this option, I could easily see what needs migrated and what doesn't instead of hoping that I find them all. I know that someone could say 'just check out all the files and migrate them' but when your Vault has over 1.5 million files a growing it's not really an option.
6 Kudos
francesco.tonioni

Purge enhancements

Status: New Idea
by Product Support on ‎10-17-2014 06:32 AM

Due to the huge impact of the purge operation on SQL and on replication performance in particular, would be useful to receive from the purge command and estimation about the number of files that will be purged and associated records to be replicated prior to the purge run.
Also would like to have a more selective purge, for example by folder, in order to split the purge workload through different weeks.

7 Kudos
Neil_Cross

ECO Properties Don't Follow The Rules

Status: New Idea
by *Expert Elite* on ‎10-06-2014 04:51 AM

All Vault properties are subject to rules such as "Requires Value" and "Minimum Length".  If a property does not have a Value or meet the minimum length, a property non-compliance is raised and requires user input to rectify.  This is really important for when a property must be completed for audit purposes and especially for exporting data into ERP systems.  

 

ECO properties have these rules but they are completely ignored.  I need to make sure users enter a value for these ECO properties but the only method in which I have to enforce this is not working, at all.  Please fix ASAP.

 

ECO Property.jpg

5 Kudos

From what I can tell right now, users have very limited control over the visibility of file records in the Thin Client.  You can either see all versions of a document or all Released versions of a document.  Both options can lead to confusion based on workflow.

 

What if you want to only show the latest Released version of a file record?  You can't do that - all Released versions are currently displayed.  Worse, what if you use a lifecycle like the built-in Flexible Release Process and perform a Quick Change?  Now you have two versions at a particular revision.  The result can be something like this:

 

 

TC_Version_Problem_Example.png

 

To provide better control over file record visibility in the Thin Client, I'd like to see the options for File visibility expanded to a total of four (from the two we have now).  These four options would be as follows:

 

  1. Show all file versions
  2. Show all Released file versions (allow multiple versions at the same Revision)
  3. Show all Released file versions (show only the latest version of each Revision)
  4. Show only the latest Released file version

I think one and four are self explanatory.  Two and three might be confusing to the user, but I think they're ultimately necessary.  Option two would function like the current 'show only released' versions, and would lead to a list like the screen capture above.  Option three would be new functionality, and would hide all Released versions of a particular Revision level except for the latest.  This option would hide versions that had been superseded by activities like Quick Change, and so in the example screen capture above, version 6 of the file would not be visible in the Thin Client.

Status: Under Review

Thank you for your feedback.  We will take a look at this and see what we can do.

4 Kudos
xdumont

Use path as a condition

Status: Comments Requested
by Mentor on ‎10-30-2014 12:21 AM

Hello,

 

Can you add the possibilité to use the path of the file for a condition (rules, transition).

 

This will be very usefull in this case:

Departement A works in $\designs\DepA => all files must fall in a DepA Category

Departement B works in $\designs\DepB => all files must fall in a DepB Category

 

Thanks in advance

Status: Comments Requested

Have you tried using Data Stanadards to see if this will do what you are requesting?

17 Kudos

We have the following situation:

 

We have an approval document that we attach to a drawing. That document only pertains to that one drawing. When using Copy Design on this drawing, however, it will keep the link to the approval document. This forces the user to go find the link and delete it. If they forget, it causes confusion. The same problem exists with properties, copy design does not offer an option to clear out properties when copying (as far as I know).

 

What we would like:

 

  • An option to strip attachments from files when copying a design.
  • An option to strip properties from files when copying a design.
Status: Implemented

This has been implemented in Copy Design 2015 R2 - here users can display and remove attachments and reset or set properties to blank.

30 Kudos

Vault report templates use an older RDLC file format.  Because of the older format, newer versions of Visual Studio cannot be used to edit these files.

 

The biggest advantage of the old RDLC format is that there are free editors available.  I tested out Visual Stuido Express 2010 and 2012, and they do not support RDLC editing.  I'm not sure if there are any free third-party editors for the new format.

5 Kudos

I was going to make this as a tongue-in-cheek troll post, but then I figured there is a serious side to it.

It's with regards to one of my previous Idea posts:

 

http://forums.autodesk.com/t5/vault-ideastation/eco-properties-don-t-follow-the-rules/idi-p/5318891

 

Essentially, there's an option to enforce a value for ECO properties.  But as confirmed by Autodesk, it isn't supported therefore it doesn't actually do anything even though the option is there, leading you to believe it should work:

 

http://forums.autodesk.com/t5/vault-general-discussion/eco-properties-can-t-enforce/m-p/5321827#M547...

 

My Idea is... if something doesn't work, isn't supported, can't function for whatever technical reason, remove the option from the product or grey it out.  

 

I honestly don't mind if something isn't supported.  I do mind wasting an hour or two scratching my head blowing time trying to make it work when all along the code behind the option just isn't there, it's disabled, it's wasted my time and annoyed me to boot.  

 

This isn't restricted specifically to ECO properties, this applies to all other red herring empty duff options in Vault.  The Item watermark 'transparent' colour option is one of a few I could back this up with! :smileytongue:

17 Kudos

I completely agree with the original poster.

http://forums.autodesk.com/t5/Vault-General/New-thin-web-client-Subscription-Release-1-sucks/m-p/455...

 

It's not clear how to View or Download the drawing and I'm IT. The average shop floor worker is not generally computer-savvy and will have an even more difficult time. They will not be able to figure out that they need to HOVER over the thumbnail then click on an small icon. Then click the DWF icon after that... (also see this wish http://forums.autodesk.com/t5/Vault-IdeaStation/Sub-Release-Thin-Web-Client-Allow-for-resize-of-DWF-...

 

Here is an example of what I'd like to see (I'm slightly exagerating on the size!). Thank you.

 

New 2014 Web Client-ViewDownload Buttons.png

Status: Under Review
Submit Your Ideas

Share and shape product ideas.

New Idea
You are not logged in.

Log into access your profile, ask and answer questions, share ideas and more. Haven't signed up yet? Register

Top Kudoed Authors