Announcements
IMPORTANT. Forum in Read Only mode. You can no longer submit new questions or replies. Please read this message for details
Autodesk Architectural Desktop 2007 & Prior
Welcome to Autodesk’s Autodesk Architectural Desktop 2007 & Prior Forums. Share your knowledge, ask questions, and explore popular Autodesk Architectural Desktop 2007 & Prior topics.
cancel
Showing results for 
Show  only  | Search instead for 
Did you mean: 

Bug?? - Shaped windows etc.

1 REPLY 1
Reply
Message 1 of 2
Anonymous
132 Views, 1 Reply

Bug?? - Shaped windows etc.

When I use a window with an arched (or trapezoid, or anything that uses RISE
in the dialog box) head, it is not drawn the way I think it should be.
For instance, with an arched window, 1410 wide, if I specify a head height
of 2460, and a rise of 250, I would expect that the apex of the arch is at
2460, and the "shoulder" to be at 2210. BUT the "shoulder" is at 2187.93. To
get the shoulder to be 2210, I've got to use trial and error and end up with
the rise set at round 229.26.
I've just tried changing the window style to peaked and trapezoid, and for
each different style, the rise required is different, AND even the head
height that is set at 2460, is drawn at a different height for each style.
To me, this is quite serious. If I want to insert a window with a raking
head of say 25 degrees, I use the window width x tan 25degrees to get the
rise, but when the window is inserted it comes out wrong.

I've done a search of the newsgroup with no sign of this problem being
mentioned. I find it hard to believe that I'm the only person to notice
this.

Thanks,

--
Chris.

Chris Needham Design & Draughting,
Whangarei,
New Zealand.
1 REPLY 1
Message 2 of 2
Anonymous
in reply to: Anonymous



Chris,

I've noticed that the rise is figured from the inside of the frame even
when you're figuring window openings from the outside.  I've just
gotten into the habit of subtracting my frame width from the overall width
and figuring the rise from there.  Seems to work then.

Chris Needham wrote:

When I use a window with an arched (or trapezoid,
or anything that uses RISE

in the dialog box) head, it is not drawn the way I think it should
be.

For instance, with an arched window, 1410 wide, if I specify a head
height

of 2460, and a rise of 250, I would expect that the apex of the arch
is at

2460, and the "shoulder" to be at 2210. BUT the "shoulder" is at 2187.93.
To

get the shoulder to be 2210, I've got to use trial and error and end
up with

the rise set at round 229.26.

I've just tried changing the window style to peaked and trapezoid,
and for

each different style, the rise required is different, AND even the
head

height that is set at 2460, is drawn at a different height for each
style.

To me, this is quite serious. If I want to insert a window with a raking

head of say 25 degrees, I use the window width x tan 25degrees to get
the

rise, but when the window is inserted it comes out wrong.

I've done a search of the newsgroup with no sign of this problem being

mentioned. I find it hard to believe that I'm the only person to notice

this.

Thanks,

--

Chris.

Chris Needham Design & Draughting,

Whangarei,

New Zealand.



--

John W. Mumaw

Timber Frame Designer

Lost Bent Woodworking & Design

john@lostbent.com

 

Can't find what you're looking for? Ask the community or share your knowledge.

Post to forums  

Autodesk Design & Make Report