Civil 3D 2014 S.P. 1.0 - Bug ? Material calculation

[wedzisi]

Hello , we found some  mistake after ubgrading civil 3d to service pack 1.0 , in coridro section shows only one side material left or right and in table and in material list report is calculated only half section , also in sholder included only sholder material , plzz see screanshot for beter understanding

[garrett_wynne]

Sure, plus we have base structures that have superelevated properties differing from the paving.  Makes for fun modeling, but a wreck in quantities when you get only one side.

Basically, if C3D cannot give proper quantities why am I still using this?

[fcernst]

This was the first thing I wanted to test in 2015... It appears to be working again now in 2015 below with symmetrical Curb material being produced:

[nikoue]

i have check a project in 2015 and still find the material issue

[fcernst]

Really? What specifically?

I also checked Pave for 2 - 12" symmetrical lanes, it gave the correct areas.

Then I made one of those lanes 20' wide and kept the other at 12', and the total area updated correctly.

[nikoue]

i take only the half areas that i take from civil 3d 2013 which gives the correct results

[fcernst]

Interesting. Can you share that Corridor?

[nikoue]

ok

https://copy.com/G2nyTOZMKgBP4Rcb

[raptorsi]

Hello, wedsizi.

I see you made section view like i want to have. Please, can you send me that cross section in cad form. I use civil 2011.

Regards. 

[fcernst]

Getting this issue....

[nikoue]

I have use custom subassemblies. Load them into civil 3d after close and restart civil 3d and you will resolve that problem.

[fcernst]

You are modeling the road using two Baselines for the centerline, and half-road assemblies. 

When I make a Full assembly out of your two half assemblies, and use one Baseline for centerline, it works (red solid hatch are the two Materials I chose).

[nikoue]

Can you send me back the model with one baseline?

But if it works with one baseline it’s not a solution.

If you open the same model with two baselines with civil 3d 2013 and rebuilt the corridor, the materials are correct.

And it’s easier for me in such a project to work with two or more baselines.

As models became complex more baseline needed to handle them.

[fcernst]

We can agree to disagree on that.... This road model would be a lot easier to deal with by using one assembly with targets.

[nikoue]

OK but the fact is that with two baseline the program dont work correct.

Civil 3d 2013 and 2014 without sp1 have not this problem.

[fcernst]

Civil 3d 2013 and 2014 without sp1 have not this problem.

Yes, I can confirm that for 2013 now. I don't want to uninstall SP1 on 2014 to test this though.

[nikoue]

its a known issue for 2014 sp1.

I don't understand how autodesk people think.

Its a huge bug

[pault34]

Thought maybe, why fix previous versions when 2015 is out for download. Anyone check 2015 corridor behavior? I haven't searched for 2015 bugs just yet.

[vcoleman]

Is this going to be fixed.  Any idea what to do until they fix this problem besides upgrading to civil 3d 2015.

[Jay_B · Accepted solution]

FYI,

This issue has been resolved with the release of 2014 Service Pack 2.

Readme file