RC Beams with linearly changing height

[Anonymous]

Hi;

Is it possible to do a design of RC Beams with linearly changing height in built inside robot RC-module for single elements ?

There is written in help that "h2" height will be available after selection of any sub-element but it doesn't work.

In which of previous versions of Robot did it work 17,18,19 ?

I tested v.21, 2011, 2012 and no way !

Is there any way to design RC-beams - higher at supports, a real engineering problem cannot be designed with that "excellent" software  ?

Please compare the attachements (neither 3D-version nor RC-module can handle that type of crossection )

[Artur.Kosakowski]

Is it possible to do a design of RC Beams with linearly changing height in built inside robot RC-module for single elements ?

No, this is not possible as the algorithm of distribution (generation) of reinforcement for spans with the variable height is not available in the current version of Robot. The request for such option being available in the RC Beam Design module is on the wish list.

There is written in help that "h2" height will be available after selection of any sub-element but it doesn't work.

In which of previous versions of Robot did it work 17,18,19 ?

I tested v.21, 2011, 2012 and no way !

Thank you for indicating this incorrect part of Help. The option has never been available.

[legar]

...

Thank you for indicating this incorrect part of Help. The option has never been available.

It was available for a very short time in Robot 97 (I don't remember exact version number - but something between v11 to v13).

Next the option was very quickly removed - due to strange results...

From this time (almost 15 years ) there is inaccessible, grayed option in dialog box and adequate help text.

JerzyCP

[Anonymous]

Thank you very much Jurek;

15 yaers ago I did it in my mathcad alghorithm according to PN-84 and later PN:1999

I see now I have to write my own software if Robot stoped in the previous decade.

BR