This should be an easy thing. I thought I could just put a masking region in mylight fixture family, but that is not working.
What is the best way to have a 2x4 light fixture mask out the 'middle' line on a 2x2 ceiling grid coming from a linked architectural model?
Solved! Go to Solution.
I think that there are potentially two issues at work here:
1. If you are placing a recessed Light Fixture, you have to make sure that the bottom of it is not flush with the ceiling - the bottom of the fixture will have to be slightly lower than the ceiling in order to mask it.
2. There is a behavior regarding the surface patterns of "Out-Of-Discipline" elements in which they are not masked by "In-Discipline" elements. If your View is set to the Electrical Discipline, then all architectural elements (i.e. the Ceilings) are considered "Out-Of-Discipline" and thus, their surface pattern (i.e. the grid) cannot be masked by the Light Fixtures, which are of course "In-Discipline". To test, ensure that #1 above is addressed and then change your View's Discipline to Architectural. Does it mask the grid now?
Thanks for the feedback, Corey, but unfortunately I tried both those things (separately & together) and the light fixture still does not mask the ceiling grid. I even tried with a ceiling grid in my MEP model (not linked) and get the same results. It doesnt matter which discipline I set my view to, the grid will not mask.
(this should go without saying, but I am working in a 'Ceiling Plan' not a 'Floor Plan')
Any more thoughts are greatly appreciated.
Can you recreate this scenario in a new Project File (no template) and post it here? What version of Revit are you using? It might be that the physical geometry of the Family is not visible in Plan/RCP Views so that there is nothing visible to mask the ceiling. Another simple thing is to check if your View is set to Visual Style: Wireframe. Or by chance, the Lighting Fixtures Category is set with Transparency.
Ok, here it is. The only thing I've been able to figure out, is that the 'architectural' troffer light [that ships with Revit MEP 2013 (Update 3) that I'm on], is that troffer family is ceiling hosted and has an 'opening cut' in the ceiling. But as far as I can tell, that is not an option in a workplane hosted family which is what I'm using. I'm also going to upload this to my Subscription support to see what their thoughts are. Thanks Corey.
Alright - I've downloaded your file and am looking at View "FIRST FLOOR LIGHTING PLAN".
I got the fixture to mask the ceiling grid by (A) changing the View's Discipline to "Architectural" or "Coordination", (B) Changing the View's Visual Style to "Hidden Line", and (C) editing the Family so that the bottom of the Light FIxture extends beyond the host face and reloaded it. See image below.
Corey, thank you. You nailed it! Those 3 things, all set 'correctly' (at least to what Revit wants) do result in the ceiling grid being masked. Also, I tweaked my light fixture family so that the extrusion extends 1/4" below the ceiling, this allows the light fixture to be 'inserted' at at even 8'-0" and still cause the masking behavior we want. Too bad the views get re-sorted into 'Architectural' group, but that's minor. At least it will print a lot better now.
Your efforts are very much appreciated.
Note: I have not yet added the 'masking' region to this one.