• Industries
  • Products
  • Buy
  • Services & Support
  • Communities
  • Autodesk Simulation Mechanical and Multiphysics

    Reply
    Valued Contributor
    Posts: 65
    Registered: ‎06-10-2008

    FEA Results vs Experience

    255 Views, 4 Replies
    06-22-2011 03:29 PM

    I've been working on a large frame sructure for some time and I'd like to be fairly confident that my results are good. I've tested the structure every way I know how (Linear) many times over in the design process in both Inventor FEA and Algor Simulation, but I lack the experience to know if the design will work in the real world like it does in the digital world. As well, the stucture we're building is expensive so building and testing prototypes really isn't an option. I could use an expert opinion from anyone out there who has real world experience with something like this. I've attached the file.

     

    Thanks in Advanced!

     

    Jason

    Please use plain text.
    Mentor
    Posts: 172
    Registered: ‎05-05-2007

    Re: FEA Results vs Experience

    06-23-2011 04:06 AM in reply to: jpealo

    Hi Jason,

    i doubt that anyone here will be able to help you by just taking a look at the picture you have posted. The only chance to get someones opinion will be to post the files that show loads and constraints. Even then it will be hard to predict if your calculations are right because one of the most common mistakes is the use of wrong loads.

     

    HTH Matthias 

    Nihil Ex Nihilo
    Please use plain text.
    Valued Contributor
    Posts: 65
    Registered: ‎06-10-2008

    Re: FEA Results vs Experience

    06-23-2011 07:43 AM in reply to: M.Peppel
    M.Peppel, Thanks for the res
    Please use plain text.
    Valued Contributor
    Posts: 65
    Registered: ‎06-10-2008

    Re: FEA Results vs Experience

    06-23-2011 07:45 AM in reply to: M.Peppel

    I'm not sure why the last message cut off. Thanks for the response. I'd be happy to email you the file.

    Please use plain text.
    Mentor
    Posts: 172
    Registered: ‎05-05-2007

    Re: FEA Results vs Experience

    06-23-2011 08:46 AM in reply to: jpealo

    Hello Jason,

    i would suggest to upload the file to a free file hosting service and post the download link here. This way it is available to other experienced users also without posting there email-adress within this forum.

     

    Cheers

     

    Matthias 

    Nihil Ex Nihilo
    Please use plain text.