• Industries
  • Products
  • Buy
  • Services & Support
  • Communities
  • Autodesk Quantity Takeoff

    Reply
    New Member
    Posts: 1
    Registered: ‎10-19-2007

    compare DWFs

    517 Views, 1 Replies
    01-23-2012 03:51 AM

    Hi,

    I'm trying to compare 2D DWFs exported from Revit.

    I've created them by hiding some part of a structure.

    When running the "Compare" command in QTO I receive a message that "No differencies were found".

    Am I doing something wrong or QTO is blind?

     

    Bests

    Krzysztof

     

    Please use plain text.
    Product Support
    Posts: 221
    Registered: ‎05-26-2010

    Re: compare DWFs

    02-14-2012 01:27 PM in reply to: kadach

    Krzysztof,

     

    The compare sheets function is designed to allow you to compare sheets with one another. It will run faster if one is located outside the file.

     

    For your projects, I am unsure what you are comparing. I compare your floor plan to your floor plan and there are no differences because there appear to be no differences. If you are comparing an elevation view to an elevation view with simply hidden elements, I think QTO is still seeing the hidden elements and not identifying these as changes. If you deleted geometry, I would expect different results.

     

    In order for this process to work the sheets first need to have geometric information in them. They need to be published in such a way where there is smart data behind the sheets. If you scanned two paper documents to PDF and tried to compare them in QTO, there would be no information for QTO to compare.

    You need to have your files published in such a way where there is takeoff data present.

     

    When you are in Revit:

    1.)    Click the Revit button > Export > DWF/DWFX

    2.)    On the view sheet tab, select the applicable sheets

    3.)    On the DWF properties tab check "Element Properties" and "Use standard format"

    4.)    Click "Next" and enter a path and filename for the export.

     

    I have included some sample files here for you to test this, if interested.

     

    1.)    Open a new QTO project

    2.)    Add File 1. dwf sheet to your project. This model is simply a wall in the shape of the number “1”

    3.)    in the document pane select the sheet for file 1

    4.)    Click the “Compare” button on the document palette

    5.)    Select File 2 and the main sheet for comparison. This model is simply a wall in the shape of the number “2”

    6.)    Click "OK" and the differences should display, both “1” and “2”. A new sheet view will display beneath the main sheet in the document pane.

     

    I have included a video of this process and sample files attached.

     

    Thank you for participating in our community!

     

    David Dembkoski                

     

    ADSK_logo_S_black_web.png

     

    Product Support Specialist

    Autodesk Product Support

    beyond design.png

    Please use plain text.