• Industries
  • Products
  • Buy
  • Services & Support
  • Communities
  • Discussion Groups

    Autodesk Inventor

    Reply
    Valued Contributor
    Posts: 73
    Registered: ‎11-03-2006

    Extrusion Enhancement Idea

    243 Views, 7 Replies
    08-31-2012 09:21 AM

    A great enhancement to Inventor (IMHO) would be an extrude "From" option. This option would give the ability to extrude by "Distance" but from another surface other than the sketch plane.

     

    When modelling top down, one often has cross-section sketches with components in the cross-section that are not symmetrical about the sketch plane. You can use assymetric distance extrusion in this case, but now you have to figure out how to divide your length formula into two parts so that the right proportion falls on each side whenever the model changes to a different size.

     

    An extrude "From"  option would work much better. Using this option you could pick the surface on which you wanted to start the extrusion and enter a distance formula. The part is now fully parametric. This option would be sort of like the opposite of the extrude "To" option except you could supply a distance for the part length allowing the part to begin at the "From" plane and stop short of the sketch plane or continue on through it an assymetrical amount.. It would also be like the "Between" option except that you would supply a distance rather than a second surface when the second surface is not readily available.

     

    Would anyone else find this enhancement useful?  Perhaps something like this already exists and I am just not aware of how to do it.

     

    Steve

     

     

     

    Please use plain text.
    New Member
    khornocker
    Posts: 1
    Registered: ‎12-16-2011

    Re: Extrusion Enhancement Idea

    08-31-2012 10:08 AM in reply to: ad64

    SolidWorks has this and its great.

    Please use plain text.
    Valued Contributor
    Posts: 98
    Registered: ‎10-20-2001

    Re: Extrusion Enhancement Idea

    08-31-2012 10:12 AM in reply to: ad64

    I like it! You could use the following work around in some cases today.

     

    1.  Create a work plane offset from the "From" surface (gives you a distance to play with).
    2.  Use the Between option for the extrude. Between the "From" surface and the offset work plane.

    You can then adjust the extrusion distance by updating the work plane offset.

     

    Please use plain text.
    Employee
    MingweiGao
    Posts: 79
    Registered: ‎08-04-2011

    Re: Extrusion Enhancement Idea

    09-02-2012 07:31 PM in reply to: ad64

    A good suggestion, Steve! A wish list has been logged into our tracking system and the ID is 1471675.


    Mingwei Gao
    Software QA Engineer
    Inventor Quality Assurance Team

    Please use plain text.
    Valued Contributor
    Posts: 73
    Registered: ‎11-03-2006

    Re: Extrusion Enhancement Idea

    04-02-2013 12:15 PM in reply to: MingweiGao

    Is there any way to check the status of this idea using the tracking number (1471615) in Ideastation or otherwise?

     

    Steve

    Please use plain text.
    Employee
    MingweiGao
    Posts: 79
    Registered: ‎08-04-2011

    Re: Extrusion Enhancement Idea

    04-02-2013 05:52 PM in reply to: ad64

    Hi Steve,

     

    This only can be checked in our internal issue tracking system and I saw it(1471675) is confirmed and still on Open status.

     


    Mingwei Gao
    Software QA Engineer
    Inventor Quality Assurance Team

    Please use plain text.
    Valued Contributor
    Posts: 73
    Registered: ‎11-03-2006

    Re: Extrusion Enhancement Idea

    04-03-2013 05:41 AM in reply to: MingweiGao

    What does "Open" status mean? Should I also add it to Ideastation so that it can get more visibility and therefore be more likely to be included in Inventor in the near future?

     

    Steve

    Please use plain text.
    *Expert Elite*
    Posts: 5,604
    Registered: ‎12-01-2004

    Re: Extrusion Enhancement Idea

    04-03-2013 07:13 AM in reply to: ad64

    ad64 wrote:

    What does "Open" status mean? Should I also add it to Ideastation so that it can get more visibility and therefore be more likely to be included in Inventor in the near future?

     

    Steve


    There are more than likely hundreds of "requested features" in the open status.. It means it could be in the next release or nothing will happen at all. Pretty sure that request has been submitted many times over already but other users, and we haven't seen it yet.

    Please click "Accept as Solution" if this response answers your question.
    -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
    2012 Product Design Suite Ultimate
    Windows 7 64 bit
    90G OCZ SATA 3 SSD (My SSD is faster than your HDD)
    Core I7 920 processor, ATI HD6970 graphics card, 12G Corsair RAM


    Please use plain text.